20:33, 27th Mar 2011
-Kobas-: Status: Rejected
19:23, 25th Mar 2011
-Kobas-: Status: Pending
10:55, 24th Mar 2011
-Kobas-: Status: Rejected

Dude, the terrain is way too plain, there is no in-game description, the map reads as a one player map, suggested players is any, and the gameplay isn't much at all. It's just a melee map and a unit spawning and going to attack the enemies base. And there's no trees! And one of your triggers caused my peasant to go and attack the enemies base when the footman spawned.

I give it a 1/5 and a [highlight]vote for rejection[/code].

19:23, 25th Mar 2011
-Kobas-:
Status: Pending
Status set to pending because author kindly requested another chance and updated map.

Version – 1.0 Recently Updated so please ignore first review

Click to expand...

Hahaha, what kinda stuff are you tryin' to pull? Dude, I didn't leave the Hive or anything just because you updated your map. I'm still here. Could have just put updated and left it at that. People can see the date of my post and the date you last updated your map.

Oh, and just to let you know, this map's only got two downloads (right now) and that was me both times.

I'll test it again and see what I think.

EDIT:

OK, I tested it again and I really think you should add some game info or something in the Quest Log. The game is a little better, but now you have this big cloud of wind blowing across the screen that could slow down some people's computers. Myself, I really don't like it and I think it's just stupid. You should just add a command to disable the effect. Like this:

The map seems kind of dead too. It's almost the same as a melee game. As a matter of fact, I think you should add Altered Melee to the map type.

Just giving my suggestions and constructive criticism, that's all. Don't take my review the wrong way. Use it to improve your map.

85 views and only 2 downloads?
Doesn't anyone even want to try it????????????!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Arth99 said:

85 views and only 2 downloads?
Doesn't anyone even want to try it????????????!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Click to expand...

Well at least now you know why we request high quality in all aspects!
Map description is really bad, why not to add some screenshots or you tube video, pictures of hero abilities, add colors and so on...

Arth99 said:

85 views and only 2 downloads?
Doesn't anyone even want to try it????????????!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Click to expand...

Nope, just me. Didn't even like though. You should try EpicWar.com.

Slayer14 said:

Oh, and just to let you know, this map's only got two downloads (right now) and that was me both times.

Click to expand...

Honestly this is the best map description I’ve ever made.

Comon you can't say that you don't like the hero pics

Yeah, they're epic, but they're just melee heroes and the map looks nothing like that ingame, at all.

Btw, I just noticed your sig, "Modern War by Arth99"? Lol, I got a map with that same name!

Slayer14 said:

Btw, I just noticed your sig, "Modern War by Arth99"? Lol, I got a map with that same name!

Click to expand...

Have you already made it? I’m somewhere around 25 to 30% done.
I’ll put a BETA out in a weeks’ time.

Arth99 said:

Have you already made it? I’m somewhere around 25 to 30% done.
I’ll put a BETA out in a weeks’ time.

Click to expand...

Yeah, mine is complete. Click on the My Maps link in my sig if you want to check it out.

Can I still use this name cause I have no other ideas plz.

Oh OK, but from this point on when you mention your map, please put the author name and I'll try to do the same.

I checked map and I'm really disappointed...
Red player own group of swordsman units on map center around that fountain.
All together 20 things changed.
Terrain is really bad.

Please use map development forum next time.