- Joined
- Dec 17, 2009
- Messages
- 1,114
i hope zerox wins!!!!
o.o!!
mwehehehe, if only he pops out his ability of making models!
anyway, good luck guys!
o.o!!
mwehehehe, if only he pops out his ability of making models!
anyway, good luck guys!
i hope zerox wins!!!!
o.o!!
mwehehehe, if only he pops out his ability of making models!
anyway, good luck guys!
She is, but she act's like a boy o_<
Everything else aside; Is there an estimated time that judging will be done?
"... compared to finished models..."
I found that funny considering there were at least half that submitted finished ones. Besides that finished applied many ways. But I'll just be patient I suppose. No need to rush the judges.
Well, I talked to DonDustin, he said judging may take up to a week, so next Wednesday to Friday.
I want to see what I got, anyway you can speed up?
Thanks for the progress update. So is the poll not coming until after judging?
Good to know judge is finished, good job guys. Eventhough... mini-contests were supposed to have no polls...since they're meant to be fast. And this one, which is supposed to be even faster (beta has a limited time and contest lasted only 5 days), while it has unfinished entries, should have a poll? =/
Of course it is interesting to connect it to the community, but... you know. We never had those with contests that gave us much more time.
No, the poll is counting into the judging.
With unifinished entries a poll is even less reasonable.I think the poll is not really needed, but we can see which model the community prefers
Pyramidhe@d said:Perenial Bison - tee_dubs
- Mesh - 10/10
Pretty much perfect- Skin - 5/5
Good ingame use. it has that prmitive orgasm look- Creativity 10/10
Orginal25/25Skullorb - Zerox
- Mesh - 9/10
Clever. but it doesnt seem..."complete" in some way- Skin - 5/5
Good ingame use. Would have prefered an animatd texture for the belly though- Creativity 7/10
New clever unit. Unoriginal shape21/25Scantid - HappyCockroach
- Mesh - 10/10
Pretty much perfect- Skin - 5/5
Good ingame use. Very SC/zerg feeling- Creativity 3/10
Existing unit. not very original18/25TerranKid08 - Kitabake
- Mesh - 8/10
Gove various bits and pieces. interesting.- Skin - 4/5
Good crisp use of ingame skin- Creativity 3/10
Just a baby marine16/25firebat kid - Amigurumi
- Mesh - 7/10
Got various bits and pieces. interesting.- Skin - 4/5
Good crisp use of ingame skin- Creativity 3/10
Just a baby Firebat.15/25Scorpiobot - Midnighter
- Mesh - 7/10
Complex mesh. rahter unneccesary though- Skin - 4/5
Good crisp use of ingame skin- Creativity 4/10
mechanical scorpion. doesnt really fit sc.15/25Looterzerg – hailfireer
- Mesh – 7/10
Good mesh- Skin – 4/5
Decent use of custom skin- Creativity – 4/10
zergling with armour. Not very creative i would think. especially considering the parts you chose to put together.15/25Terralisk - supertoinkz
- Mesh - 5/10
Looks very messy.- Skin - 3/5
Decent- Creativity 6/10
tried to give an original creature. Idea didnt show quite through.14/25Murloc Reaper – varsaigen
- Mesh – 3/10
Decent mesh, the rockets are irregular though- Skin – 3/5
Utilised it failrly well- Creativity – 3/10
Looks more like a baby reaper rather than a murloc10/25SpaceCowCritter - Fan
- Mesh – 5/10
Decent mesh, the rockets are irregular though- Skin – 3/5
Utilised it failrly well- Creativity – 6/10
its a flying cow. in space. goes well in terms of idea but the model itself has been left rather barren.13/25infestedrobot – heroslayer
- Mesh – 4/10
shape is decent, the wrap is complete mess- Skin – 0/5
no idea what is going on here.- Creativity – 2/10
A random robot with tentacles.Didnt fit the theme. The mesh looks more like some chromehound mechTotal – 6/25ZerglingPup - Xndr
- Mesh – 4/10
mediocre- Skin – 1/5
Dont really see the need for the skin- Creativity – 3/10
not very original. just a baby of something. actually. doesnt look baby at all.Total – 8/25BabyOverlord – sooda
- Mesh – 3/10
i see a lot of stretched primitives and etc- Skin – 1/5
You really havent utilised the space given not to mention the skin doesnt fit the thing at all- Creativity – 3/15
not very original. just a baby of somethingTotal – 6/25
DonDustin said:HailFireer – LooterZerg:
Mesh: It is pretty much the generic wc3 zerg with marine chest armor. --> 2/10
Texture: They fit well. --> 3/5
Creativity: I think such a unit would be quite creative in sc2, but for a contest it is quite boring. --> 2/10
==> 7/25
HappyCockroach – Scantid:
Mesh: Quite low poly, how you would expect it for a critter. But it still got detail where you would expect it. --> 10/10
Texture: The chosen textures are really really creative. I would have never thought of using the mushroom texture for the body. --> 5/5
Creativity: The idea is really nice, but it still reminds of known elements of Zerg units --> 8/10
==> 23/25
Midnighters - ROBO-SCORPION
Mesh: The mesh seems ok, but it uses too many faces. --> 3/10
Texture: They fit, but there are a few unwrap issues. --> 2/5
Creativity: It is nice, but nothing special. --> 3/10
==> 8/25
Fan – Space Cow
Mesh: It is nice, but there could have been used less faces here and there. --> 5/10
Texture. They fit quite well, but are a bit generic. The unwrap could have been better in certain ares aswell. --> 4/5
Creativity. The idea itself is rather hilarious, but as it actually not “yours”, but debodes and because Blizzard already made the Tauren Marine, it looses a bit of its magic. --> 6/10
==> 15/25
Sooda – Baby Overlord
Mesh: It is basicly only a compilation of primitives. --> 3/10
Texture: It is plain ugly to be serious. --> 1/5
Creativity. The idea is nice, but it wasn’t executed how someone would expect it for a contest. There was more potential in it. --> 3/10
==> 7/25
Amigurumi – FirebatKiddy
Mesh: Really nice. It got all kind of details a good model needs, while staying low poly. --> 8/10
Texture: Fits well. --> 4/5
Creativity: Might not be the best idea, but it is still fine. --> 5/10
==> 17/25
Kitabatake – TerranKid
Mesh: Nice. Good everything, that a good model needs. --> 7/10
Texture. Fits well. The animated texture is a nice addition. --> 5/5
Creativity: Might not be the best idea, but it is still fine. -->5/10
==> 17/25
HeroSlayer – Infested Robot
Mesh: Seems nice, but way too high poly fort his contest. --> 3/10
Texture. The texture is not really well and I also do not even think that a custom texture is needed. --> 2/5
Creativity: I don’t see in what way this model is connected to the theme, because it does not really look like a critter to me. --> 2/10
==> 7/25
Xndr – Zergling Pup
Mesh. The mesh is decent. --> 5/10
Texture: I don’t see how this model needs a custom texture and the unwrap is really messy. --> 2/5
Creativity. The idea is nice, but it wasn’t executed how someone would expect it for a contest. There was more potential in it. --> 3/10
==> 10/25
supertoinkz – Terralisk
Mesh: Actually pretty good, but the rocks make it appear a bit messy. Some stone skin instead might have been a better idea for your concept. --> 6/10
Texture: I really like your texture choice and the idea of the rocks that change their desing based on the terrain is really original. --> 5/5
Creativity: I think everyone can see that you made some thoughts when creating it. --> 7/10
==> 18/25
tee.dubs – Perennial Bison
Mesh: The mesh is well done, but might be a tad “high poly” for a critter. --> 9/10
Texture: Fits very well --> 5/5
Creativity: This model fits perfectly to the theme. It might be dangerous in WC universe, but harmless in the world of SC. --> 10/10
==> 24/25
Zerox – Skullborb
Mesh: The mesh is perfect for a critter model. --> 10/10
Textures: They fit very well. --> 5/5
Creativity: It is really creative, but it reminds me a bit too much of the SC2 baneling. --> 9/10
==> 24/25
varsaigen – MurlocReaper
Mesh: the mesh is ok. It could be made with less faces in some areas, especially because you are using a custom texture. --> 6/10
Texture: A lot of blank space, it misses shading, and contrast to me, and I think it would have been great if you wouldn’t have it completely covered in armor, but leaving certain Murloc body parts visible. --> 2/5
Creativity: It is like a counter part of the SC2 Tauren Marine. Not that creative, but still nice. --> 6/10
==> 14/25