WaterShimmera.blp

[Moderator]

17:14, 1st Sep 2008
Dan van Ohllus:
[Rejected]
The main purpose is that you should notice the custom skin ingame, and what I see here is an awful lack of shading (and in some parts lack of definition), using cheap gradient filter, plus it looks very pixelated and messy on the unshaded parts.

Please check out the tutorials on the forum and learn to improve if you wish to have future skins approved.

 

[Hawkwing]

Most of the texture is just unshaded colour, and the stuff that does have shadows was made through a Gradient Filter. All other changes were made through recolour.

 

[Jack_Sparrow93]

Nice done!

 

[mikle splat]

Most of the texture is just unshaded colour, and the stuff that does have shadows was made through a Gradient Filter. All other changes were made through recolour.

dont judge it by the skin because in warcraft you see the model, so look at the lovely model!

 

[Hawkwing]

This is a Skin Resource Section, not a model resource section. There is no reason for anyone not to judge the texture.

 

[mikle splat]

This is a Skin Resource Section, not a model resource section. There is no reason for anyone not to judge the texture.

yer im just saying that in warcraft you dont see the skin, you see the model.

 

[Hawkwing]

You do indeed see the model, though you see the skin just as well.

 

[mikle splat]

You do indeed see the model, though you see the skin just as well.

yer but the model is the whole thing, the end product ;-)

 

[Grog50]

Not really lol...Noob Vs Hawk round 4! 3...2...1...start!

 

[FrIkY]

Not really lol...Noob Vs Hawk round 4! 3...2...1...start!

ROFL!! Omg that was so funny... lol!

As for this skin, it's lacking shadows and highlights and parts are recolored 2/5

 

[Misha]

Most of the texture is just unshaded colour, and the stuff that does have shadows was made through a Gradient Filter. All other changes were made through recolour.

Agree! but this one looks nice
Must do:
1 add shades and highlights to spots there is only color
2 add body texture also to the blank color spots
3 try to use frehand.
4 give more definition.
5 do not recolor.

Tagged: 3.56 Nice! ^^

 

[X.e.r.e.X]

dont judge it by the skin because in warcraft you see the model, so look at the lovely model!

I lol'd D:
Why did you even make a skin if you think that it's not noticeable in game?

 

[cHeRoL]

His head looks creepy.

 

[Elven Spellmake]

I agree with the noob then, it looks lovely ingame...

 

[oh_snap]

In game it is still clearly lacking the things Hawkwing mentioned. That said I don't get why so many people are critical of criticism, it is there to help, not hurt. Do you expect to get better through praise? It does not look too bad in game. That said would the skin not benefit from the things Misha and Hawkwing mentioned? And please don't argue with me, If I wanted to argue I would join the debate team...