Toxic Potion

[Panda]

Try not to use that gray backgrounds anymore, it throws off the quality of the overall icon when finished. The green go inside the bottle, i don't like those parts that are coming upwards, they look really weird. I would maybe add bubbles coming from the goo instead of those lines coming up.

 

[PrinceYaser]

Try not to use that gray backgrounds anymore, it throws off the quality of the overall icon when finished. The green go inside the bottle, i don't like those parts that are coming upwards, they look really weird. I would maybe add bubbles coming from the goo instead of those lines coming up.

This!

 

[GhostThruster]

not bad, but could use improvements. as the panda suggested, gray backgrounds aren't that suitable for wc3 icons. to be honest though i don't think it's too bad in this case.

the liquid's surface needs highlights to match the light source implied by your shading of the flask/bottle, whilst the corkscrew needs shading.

 

[San]

The grey background has killed the icon, substandard as the author is not willing to update it.