Rexxar Remar

[StormKnight]

Yeah so, here's the thing, i love those team color tints wrapping around the shoulders and the weapons, about time someone used it to good effect since the days of the Berserk SFX. the tiny armor bits on his feet/belt are great, the new axes shape and quality, attractive.

aaaaaand i'll probably edit out the skull chin if i use it. and i almost forgot to say, you rock.

 

[Stefan.K]

Yeah so, here's the thing, i love those team color tints wrapping around the shoulders and the weapons, about time someone used it to good effect since the days of the Berserk SFX. the tiny armor bits on his feet/belt are great, the new axes shape and quality, attractive.

aaaaaand i'll probably edit out the skull chin if i use it. and i almost forgot to say, you rock.

Yeah, basically he did everything great, but was too lazy(?) to wrap the skull sholder pad and the skull armor on his arm better.

 

[BaiyuGalan]

Yeah so, here's the thing, i love those team color tints wrapping around the shoulders and the weapons, about time someone used it to good effect since the days of the Berserk SFX. the tiny armor bits on his feet/belt are great, the new axes shape and quality, attractive.

aaaaaand i'll probably edit out the skull chin if i use it. and i almost forgot to say, you rock.

Thank you for your like!About his skull chin. I'm based on Storm the Heroes.

 

[BaiyuGalan]

Yeah, basically he did everything great, but was too lazy(?) to wrap the skull sholder pad and the skull armor on his arm better.

Because this is the decoration of Warcraft III. It's flat.

 

[Stefan.K]

Because this is the decoration of Warcraft III. It's flat.

That's why you must manipulate with the vertices to get a better look. It took me two minutes to make it look better:

 

[StormKnight]

Thank you for your like!About his skull chin. I'm based on Storm the Heroes.

You can easily merge your reply to Stefan inside the reply to me so its not a double post.
but anyway, i didn't know about Hots version of this skin, it looks pretty interesting and nice but even on that i just don't agree with that skull chin existing, its a whole neck there 😳

Not that you should remove it though i was just voicing my opinion.

 

[BaiyuGalan]

You can easily merge your reply to Stefan inside the reply to me so its not a double post.
but anyway, i didn't know about Hots version of this skin, it looks pretty interesting and nice but even on that i just don't agree with that skull chin existing, its a whole neck there 😳

Not that you should remove it though i was just voicing my opinion.

I'm not very good at using the hive of function.

 

[aeman]

that one beautiful pair of axe

 

[Wazzz]

why his hammer an axe?

looks pretty nice, though, loving the work

 

[BaiyuGalan]

why his hammer an axe?

looks pretty nice, though, loving the work

This is the skill name

 

[ILH]

Please add an in-game screenshot and rename the model files in the pack so that they're easily identifiable.

 

[General Frank]

Might be useful for some people. A bit too simple edit.

 

[StormKnight]

Considering that This and This also exist, i personally think this model should have either been approved, or it was set in the Useful section just very barely missing the Approved mark.

I like it alot anyway 🙂

 

[Stefan.K]

Considering that This and This also exist, i personally think this model should have either been approved, or it was set in the Useful section just very barely missing the Approved mark.

I like it alot anyway 🙂

Don't want to start some drama, but most of the Johnwar's models are simple retextures and they also get approved.

 

[StormKnight]

Don't want to start some drama, but most of the Johnwar's models are simple retextures and they also get approved.

I wouldn't say simple, they bring alot to of change, they're not like any regular reskin we've seen and most of the times come in several different versions so its not a "singular" version of "A" model, while a more light-hearted yet no less awesome one would be our Lord and Savior Grand Master Ujimasa Hojo (May God bless his soul)'s work.

I dont want to argue with the moderators though about this, they probably know alot better.

 

[BaiyuGalan]

Considering that This and This also exist, i personally think this model should have either been approved, or it was set in the Useful section just very barely missing the Approved mark.

I like it alot anyway 🙂

Thank you for your like.

 

[Xetanth87]

Might be useful for some people. A bit too simple edit.

As @StormKnight said, why isn't this one approved, considering Johnwar's Rexxar had a similar review, but got aproved?

@ILH's review:

 

[General Frank]

Author is okay with the model being in simple/useful. This was solved in a private conversation and is NOT open to public.

 

[BaiyuGalan]

I don't think so.😅

 

[General Frank]

I don't think so.😅

Excuse me? What do you want more?
You are being straight up unreasonable now. You said you are okay with your models being in simple.

 

[BaiyuGalan]

Obviously, I mean I'd rather use effective / simple than restricted.I don't think my model is very simple.If you have any objection to my words. I think you should make the private conversation public.

 

[General Frank]

Obviously, I mean I'd rather use effective / simple than restricted.I don't think my model is very simple.

Then make it better.
I told you so in the personal message I sent you yesterday. I am not your enemy neither I want to be vindictive to you.

Please respond to the PM I sent you so we can get things straight, okay?

Making a private conversation public is against the rules.

 

[Commedia]

Excuse me? What do you want more?
You are being straight up unreasonable now. You said you are okay with your models being in simple.

In any case, can you give the reasons why Johnwar's Rexxar is approved but BaiyuGalan's is simple? There are so many people thinking BaidyGalan's Rexxar is a good model. I don't think you should explain this by "useful for someone".

 

[General Frank]

In any case, can you give the reasons why Johnwar's Rexxar is approved but BaiyuGalan's is simple? There are so many people thinking BaidyGalan's Rexxar is a good model. I don't think you should explain this by "useful for someone".

johnwars' model is more optimized, more fitting into wc3, better looking that this model.
Also, johnwar actually listens to input and does not cause drama and is reasonable.

But we should not compare models.

 

[Ralle]

But we should not compare models.

As the rules state. Resource moderation is case-by-case. Different staff sees different things. If all staff members have to look at the same model, we will never get ajour with the moderation queue.

People often want to compare old model moderations with new ones. That is meaningless as the standards in the past were lower than they are now.

However, seeing as this model is compared to a recently submitted one. It might be possible to compare. The difference is that Frank moderated this one and @ILH moderated johnwar's model. Even they most likely have differing standards despite trying to be on the same page. This is allowed. It's why we allow people to ask for a second opinion.

johnwars' model is more optimized, more fitting into wc3, better looking that this model.

@ILH already looked over this moderation and agrees with it.

 

[DarkePacific]

Any chance you could add an attack alternate/throw? Really love this but need a version where it looks like he's throwing his axes on attack.

 

[BaiyuGalan]

Any chance you could add an attack alternate/throw? Really love this but need a version where it looks like he's throwing his axes on attack.

I will not add new actions or modify actions.But when he uses spells. The axe behind it will disappear for a while.