Ok, now I can see what's going on in this skin... well, first of all... it doesn't have enough material for approval... around 50% of the skin is retone/recolor, but you need at least 75% freehand in order to get it approved (+ all the other skin submission stuff...). Those bandages could also use more work, they blur out ingame, you must sharpen them, sharpen them good... use the "Sharpen Filter". For the that, I recommend you to study
this tutorial and use it's tactic! Make new pants, blades and that "badge" thingy, where Pandaren's head was drawn before.
Short list of what you need to change:
- Shade those bandages little bit more
- Make new hair
- Make new blades
- make new "badge"
- sharpen!
Useful Tip!
When making a skin, size it to 512x512... make your skin, and then re-size it back to 256x256 back again!
You'll have to draw more, but... then you'll also have better results with your skin!
Right now, your grade will be:
2/
5 - Lacking
But off course, you'll work harder on it next time when you update it, and when you make your skin look better, the grade will be better too! ^^
I'm just being friendly and helpful!