BTNWaterSword

[Moderator]

15:21, 19th Apr 2011
enjoy: Could use something in the background to make it less plain.

enjoy: No changed made. Rejected until updated.

 

[Marcos DAB]

In my opinion, is very clear. Also showing a little more handle.

 

[Banzay89]

Marcos DAB, thank you for your comments
I always try to draw nice, but not always it turns out =)

 

[Marcos DAB]

It takes just a little more work. Overall is good

 

[Orcnet]

Dat Bleeiid! Soh Good!

 

[Death-Blade]

Very nice icon, try adding water effects at the edges.
Anyway, I will give u... mmmm...............

5/5 good job!!!

 

[devilx99]

I like the pattern, also agree with Marcos, the handle part , else it looks a bit weird to me
other than that 3.8/5 overall

 

[Panda]

This needs something in the background its to simple.