BTNPotato

[Moderator]

23:39, 1st Jan 2014
Kimbo: Hi there, same with your other vege icons, I think they need to be draw in a program like gimp, it offers better tools and resources for shading. Atm its too flat, too plain.. I dont think it HAS to be into wc3 style, but it would be better if it was more iconic, graphic, popped out, stylized more. I think it also needs to be centered into the icons borders.

EDIT: ehh..better, but now its too brown and dirty. Maybe make it abit more yellow/brighter with the same shading etc so it doesnt blend into the background as much?

Sin'dorei300: No changes made.

 

[Roland]

Potatoes? potatoes? po..po...TATOES?! OH MAY!

Well, It's really perfect and lovely icon, but the problem is this Icon needs more shading and all of your Icons uploaded previously. I hope you can make it more better and I wish you can make more better, you made a great work, but needs more stronger shading.

Good~luck.

 

[darkdeathknight]

Like Roland said, the biggest problem with your icons is the shading.

 

[Guramax]

Ahehehe.., Thanks again..,

The reason that the shading is a poor because I'm only
using Paint App. I don't have Photoshop yet and I don't
know how to use it. Then again I'll try my best to make
it even better and create quality icons.

 

[Adaethus]

Shading and detail would add a lot to this icon.

If you're having trouble with programs, I suggest you try GIMP.
It's completely free and is almost as powerful as Photoshop.

 

[darkdeathknight]

Ahehehe.., Thanks again..,

The reason that the shading is a poor because I'm only
using Paint App. I don't have Photoshop yet and I don't
know how to use it. Then again I'll try my best to make
it even better and create quality icons.

GIMP is a good free alternative to Photoshop

 

[Guramax]

Done with the shading. Thanks to you all, I learned another thing or two about editing and making icons. Though my skills is not that honed, I hope the product is more acceptable now..,

I finally got rid of my lazy picture editing butt.
Again, Thank You..,

 

[Anderhil]

Cmon guys why are you arguing over the shading of a Potato? XD

Its good, and sees some perfect uses if we have a BUNCH of these icons, like, Potatoes, Turnips, Pineapples and... , all drawn in THIS style, THIS shading, THIS art.

In my opinion EVERYTHING can create its own gender.

SO good job brother. keep it up! 4/5.

 

[darkdeathknight]

It's still has to fit the style of Warcraft III icons. And there's nothing wrong with telling ways to improve.

 

[Shadow Fury]

I don't know what use may a potato have in Warcraft, perhaps a vegetable shop from which u can buy them to heal urself? Anyway, the potato looks good but obviously as every1 said it would be better with shading as it looks cartoonish. Meh, 2/5 or 3/5, better not to rate.

 

[Guramax]

Well, I made some changes... I hope it's better than the last ones.

 

[Shadow Fury]

I now feel that it looks like a chocolate cookie. U really need to download a photo-editing program like Photoshop because this icon is far too simple and cartoonish.

 

[Anderhil]

i'm raising the rating to 5/5. for the effort you put on it. good job.

 

[Guramax]

i'm raising the rating to 5/5. for the effort you put on it. good job.

Thank you so much..,

 

[Heinvers]

That actually looks quite like a potato. 5/5 from me as motivation