BTNPetrify

[Moderator]

21:55, 12th Jul 2010
Pyramidhe@d: Icon is rather blurry/undefined in places. I dont like smudge. Nor does it count as freehand.

 

[The Panda]

Not very warcraftish, and im not sure what this icon is suppose to be exactly.

 

[Midnighters]

Looks like you took a picture of your hand, put it in grayscale, and added a 2 minute background to it.

 

[Xargo]

Not freehanded again OMG!!!

This is the problem with warcraft icons 64x64 is really small number of pixels. I had a lot of work drawing and shading this hand so, that it looks absolutely realistic and now I am facing the problem, that it looks like a photo lol . In case there are any doubts here is the high-def picture with visible lines.
On top of that I copyed exactly the way backgrounds are made in war3 icons.

This icon reject streak is driving me crazy!!!!!!!!
MWHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHHAHH........lolol...HAHAHHAHHAHHAHAAAAAAAA!!!!!

 

[8512590215848]

The hand looks pretty good, but the bg - looks too bad. Please, try to make it some different colors, or shade it with dark blue near the hand..

 

[The Panda]

Make it look like a warcraft hand or maybe a troll hand? Just something warcraftish.

 

[Darkzealot_128]

Replace the hand with an animated hand or something so it looks better.

 

[crimson fire]

the hands fine just do something about the backround.

 

[Xargo]

Thanks for the suggestion with the blue background. It made the picture more lively and contrasting. It also geve it the coveted warcraft look. I only didn't get the complaints about non-animated hand. WTH!!!!! OMGARGHHHHHHH!!!! What did you mean?

 

[8512590215848]

add a little lightblue or deep puruple as a highline or a border of a hand. For more understand what i mean - check blizzard's Doom Icon..

In my opinion light blue should looks better than purple, but its only imo, u can experiment and make it as u like it