BTNMrelf

[Moderator]

21:09, 29th Dec 2015
Sin'dorei300: I strongly recommend you to add shading(highlights and shadows, using lighter or darker tones of your base colors), this will visibly improve your icon.
Awaiting update.

 

[Eldin HawkWing]

Is that really YourS? can you Show the Picture of your WIP.

 

[Warcraftplay]

-icon

-my draw

-reserved

 

[Eldin HawkWing]

Nice... But The Shading?
4/5 - Needs a Shading.

 

[Roland]

I recommend you to do more freehand shading.

 

[Ustanak]

Pretty nice. Was this icon inspired by this model? https://www.hiveworkshop.com/forums...yes-199896/?prev=search=Champion&d=list&r=200

 

[Eagle XI]

If you use compressed .jpg option with around 85% quality instead of palletted in button manager it could get possibly less grainy. Be sure it has saved the icon as 32 bit and not 24 bit.

 

[Roland]

Recommendations for this Icon to get approved
-Fix the symmetry for the hero
-Needs more freehand shading
-Remove the stray pixels between the lines of the icon
-Jesus Christ take out that god damn glow in that icon and make it freehand

Overall: It's decent, but still asymmetrical so I hope you can improve your icon and do your best.

 

[Moy]

The shading could be stronger, I disagree on the symmetrical thingy. It doesn't need to be symmetrically perfect imo.

As I said, the shading could be stronger. The icon itself is really great already and a small touch of shading could make this icon amazing and possibly approved. The gold part is the most obvious part to the naked eye that needs stronger shading. I recommend you to see Sin'dorei300's album to see what I mean, and learn from his artworks.

 

[Deleted member 238226]

though the shading in the big image is kinda lacking, the result after it resized is beautiful for me.

reminds me alot of how sunchips do this icon : https://www.hiveworkshop.com/forums...ggernaut4-260004/?prev=d=list&r=20&u=sunchips

 

[Eldin HawkWing]

Nice Update Warcraftplay..! 5/5
looks like LichKing's Helm .