BTNManaBreak

[Moderator]

16:27, 3rd Jul 2014
Sin'dorei300: Nice idea!

 

[Solu9]

While a nice idea it could have used some more texture.
The handle and the blade also kinda melts together due to being the same color.
Is all of it supposed to be made of iron?

Overall it's a little too cartoonish for me. But it's a fine icon nonetheless.

3/5 for the idea and the bubble is really nice too.

 

[Heinvers]

I love that effect. It's quite tiresome to get it right. I'll give a 4/5.

 

[Marcos DAB]

While a nice idea it could have used some more texture.
The handle and the blade also kinda melts together due to being the same color.
Is all of it supposed to be made of iron?

Overall it's a little too cartoonish for me. But it's a fine icon nonetheless.

3/5 for the idea and the bubble is really nice too.

I did the three weapons all in gray/metal,
because the focus is what the weapon are doing and not the weapon itself.