BTNMace2

[Moderator]

21:22, 20th May 2016
GhostThruster: spikes need shading. additionally, the handle and 'head's lighting is off due to differing light sources. the head's shadows are also too dark.
finally, as murcologist mentioned, graininess is an issue

 

[Murlocologist]

Icon is nice, I especially find the angle very good.
Here are a few things you might want to fix:
-spikes aren't properly shaded
-contrast of light and dark on head could be more balanced
-maybe more work on proper transition of the light across the head
-overall it looks a bit grainy, maybe because of sharpening tool if you used one
-handle is ok but to generic in my opinion. you could try to shade it more like this one is: