BTNLightDarkness

[Moderator]

11:27, 15th May 2010
Pyramidhe@d: That sword in the ground. Its closer than the moon and the sun so define it better. Then move the whole thing a little to the right. Right now, your icon composition is very unbalanced, too much on the left side.

17th May 2010
Pyramidhe@d: No changes made (i thought the sword was a person too)

 

[FSB]

great job. Its like "Eclipse"

 

[Etzer]

He did not just mention"Twilight" did he?

 

[terradont]

Idea = Lovely.
Execution = A little messy, especially for one of your icons. Try to make it mmore defined, the scimitar melds too much with both the ground and sky, it took me around 10 seconds to see what it was.

 

[Hemske]

He did not just mention"Twilight" did he?

Eclipse is the phenomen when the sun gets completly darkened. Not only the movie's name
About the icon, nice one, like it! The sword looks a bit round and not really that metallic, more defining of what it is and it will be great.

 

[Etzer]

Eclipse is the phenomen when the sun gets completly darkened. Not only the movie's name
About the icon, nice one, like it! The sword looks a bit round and not really that metallic, more defining of what it is and it will be great.

I know the phenomen, but he did not write Eclipse, he wrote "Eclipse."

ON:
The icon is really nice

 

[The Panda]

Overall good, but some fixes may need to be in order here, as the sword looks like a person at first glance.

 

[kola]

Overall good, but some fixes may need to be in order here, as the sword looks like a person at first glance.

yeah, took me about 10 sec to understand it wasnt a person but a sword.

 

[D4RK_G4ND4LF]

all of you have bad eyes
I think the icon is good but if there are so many people who can't recognize it you might consider to change it

 

[The Panda]

All im saying is define the sword and the Dark to Light factor.