BTNIncineration

[Moderator]

13:09, 7th Mar 2009
Paladon:

Creativity: 1/5
Quality: 1/10
Status: Rejected
Comment: Breaks the 50% freehanded rule. Appears too random, undefined and smudged. Don't use renders.

 

[Zombie]

It looks like random colors slapped together.

 

[Leeroy]

Stop spamming the icon section of useless and ugly icons.

Just aim on ONE good icon, compare your quality with others and then ask yourself "Is this approvable? Does this look like I wanted to and does other recognize it is what I wanted it to be?"
If the answers are positive, then upload it.

This one looks really random, looks like you just used polar coordinates with a few mixed colors. (which are ugly)

But the positive thing is: keep making those icons BUT don't upload them. Just practize in private and when you'll get some real confidence with icon making, upload a good icon.

EDIT: Don't use filters. They're not considered freehanded.