BTNGoldenAxe

[Moderator]

13th Nov 2009
Pyramidhe@d: The blade looks very flat as it is now. For next time, I suggest you might try making icons, not viewed flat from the side, but at and angle so you can see the top.

 

[kola]

Full size

 

[X-OMG-X]

Wow. This one really overgoes all your other icons. Awesome.

 

[kola]

ok new version.

 

[Jacky The turtle]

looks much better then your others i like you bg =D

 

[krisserz]

It`s pretty good, but I think you should make the handle thiner from the left side. Also add some shadow on the blade.

 

[Revolve]

I don't know, maybe outline it more? And the bg is a bit empty, fill it up ^^ Nice otherwise

 

[Panda]

Fix up the shape of the blade part, doesn't seem that sharp.

 

[kola]

New Version, fixed the blade shape

its gay that the quality of the image goes down when u upload it... the real one is so much better ..

 

[Pyramidhe@d]

just changing the handle to gold would have been fine.

now about the highlights,

this is what i was talking about. you need a sharp edge, represented with strong hard highlight, for your axe otherwise your axe ends up looking flat

 

[kola]

I tried making the handle gold.. it was ugly >.> lol.. it was like if i tried to make too much.. so i did like... bah 2 lil diamond will do it

 

[Pyramidhe@d]

oh ok. yeah gold handles can be a little hard.
just do the thing about the blade then

 

[kola]

ok.. but i keep the golden thing on it? (i rly like it so i might keep it) but.. the blade is completly white... i dont think i can highlight it more.. i'll just make the other part more gray..

 

[Pyramidhe@d]

if you like it, just leave it. thats ok. its your icon afterall
i guess the icon as it is right now is acceptable

 

[kola]

yeah.. but i want to make it better if u think it can be better... why wouldnt i want to update it?