BTNFireAndWater

[Moderator]

13:18, 10th Nov 2008
Hawkwing: Very messy.

 

[FrIkY]

Looks very good... but! Water could use some more work

4/5 - great job, but you could make water look more realistic (and this icon also kinda reminds me on Firefox logo, a little )

 

[Devine]

looks like an edited version of firefox icon (a bit)

 

[ANdROnIQ]

^^ also thought of firefox when created... I tried to make water of Manashield icon, but it's not that (actually, manashield isn't even water). I'll try to do something - add some little drops. or what...

DevineArmy, a bit edited or a bit looks?

EDIT: Updated. What do you say now?

 

[FrIkY]

You see how's the fire going, in which dirrection, it looks like some firebolt coming from upper left corner and continuing going to lower right corner. Try the same thing with water!

 

[ANdROnIQ]

This is not a bolt with a tail, the fire tries to strike up from under the water. And water tries to flow down through the fire. So maybe I should make some background rain at the bottom of the icon, what do you think?

 

[terradont]

The fire seems to be dominant in this icon. I'm not sure how, but you should try to add some more water. Maybe the bottom right half of the fireball can be water?

the greatest powers are born in union of the opposite elements.

What? Steam? (Sorry, just had too. I still sounds nice :])

 

[ANdROnIQ]

Fire is (in occultism) the way of honor and pride, it's when you can do everything in the name of your faith, no matter on consequences. Water is intellectual way, when you evaluate your possible actions by their hypothetical results and choose the path of highest success, even if it goes against your sights (in a local situation), but leads to a better place (globally). The union of the two is when you can fall in both extremes at one time.

P.S. Ok, I'll try to add some water.

 

[Jimnaboo]

Guess I'll go look for a different request. Cool icon. If it were me, I'd make the fire come out in front of the water a little bit here and there, 'cause that's how it would happen... I think. Okay, bad explanation. Anyway, good job.

 

[Sergeant Ray]

Textures are poorly placed, and does not look realistic. On the other hand, the texture colors, and the Idea are great. 3/5

 

[Jack_Sparrow93]

looks like an edited version of firefox icon (a bit)

Just what I thought to say!

Good job!

 

[ANdROnIQ]

Sarge: I know, looks cartoony. But isn't Warcraft a game? WoW graphics are even more cartoony (I mean 3D).

Ok, it was the last update. I wonder if I edit it again.

 

[Sergeant Ray]

I don't mean cartoony, I mean it looks nothing like fire and water.

 

[Satau]

I ithnk this icon is fucking brilliant! Makes me wanna use it for any skill in all my maps (But that would confuse the players i think ;P)

However u said u hoped it would be used as an icon for an ulti in a map, well it will be in mine Just wanted to let u know ^^

5/5