BTNFabric

[Moderator]

01:07, 9th Mar 2015
enjoy: This icon looks really nice, I just want you to add a little more contrast to it. Other than that, it's great.

16:44, 21st Mar 2015
Sin'dorei300: No changes made.
Awaiting update.

15:21, 28th May 2016
Sin'dorei300: Some changes were made, but you could still tinker with its contrast a bit.

 

[GhostThruster]

good start, needs more contrast. a back light tho unnecessary wudn't hurt, and wud add a blizzard feeling

 

[Sclammerz]

Neat icon. Good job for your first icon. 3/5!

 

[Ardenian]

A really interesting, well-made, ( for me) unseen icon.

Although, I don't like that you try to make other users pity you when reading your description. Just don't do that. Most Users will criticize you on a professional, artistically level and they surely don't want to hurt you, even if they have a bad day.

I would have one suggestion: Improve shading.
It is already well-made and correctly placed, but you could add a stronger, darker shadow under the cloth, as there is no light source and the light comes from the right-hand site top.

 

[Sunchips]

A very good first icon

 

[Kingluis]

the previous persons already said everything of my mind

3.5/5, gave 3.

 

[lokharke]

Very nice. I see nothing wrong with it.

 

[Heinvers]

The main problem seems to be the lack of stronger proper highlights on the material.

I like anyway

 

[Roland]

Smooth as fuck, but I'd probably do the suggestions of the users above

 

[HappyCockroach]

It is too soft, too smooth, etc. What else would we expect from fabric?

To me it is delicate as it should be. A nicely done icon, really. You say we're free to steal the credit, well, I would gladly do that

 

[ANdROnIQ]

And this - also for the Commodities system!