Btnbw2

[Moderator]

01:59, 25th Jan 2014
Kimbo: As I said before, the shape of the potion/bottle/water container looks abit confusing at first, looked like a cocktail glass to me. But once you put a context to it, which I REALLY REALLY wish you did add in the title/name (I will add it in the description and you can change it later) it all makes sense.

Approved

 

[Razosh]

This icon could use some more impressive glow since the background looks really dull and this also seems like something people might want to use with more than just BTN and DISBTN you should try uploading some alternatives. Other than that I think it looks really fine. 3/5

 

[Kimbo]

Took me a moment to figure out it was a potion, thought it was a cocktail drink
I'll check it out laters though

 

[Razosh]

thought it was a cocktail drink
I'll check it out laters though

Just don't try to drink a Molotov cocktail.

 

[Luorax]

This icon could use some more impressive glow since the background looks really dull and this also seems like something people might want to use with more than just BTN and DISBTN you should try uploading some alternatives. Other than that I think it looks really fine. 3/5

I'd rather he made alternative version(s) of the icon with a background. Most WC3 item icons don't have a background either, so it'd stand out quite a lot if you wanted to use it in conjunction with built-in icons.

It looks pretty good, BTW You might want to do more variations, it's sad to see a cool icon with only one variation.