Archemonde.blp

[Moderator]

15:46, 7th Jul 2008
Werewulf: Atm it looks far too..blurry and messy and the armour looks VERY poorly done, fix that up to a good quality and ill see about approval, atm it looks ..too..messy.

Edit:
Dan van Ohllus
[Rejected]
More than 10 days has went, and still no updates.

 

[Legrandray]

the brown is a bit blury but this is a good skin 4/5

 

[cHeRoL]

His cape is ugly.

 

[Hawkwing]

Negative Comments

[-] Not enough contrast.
[-] No pants. Looks like a whore.
[-] His shoulder pads are connected to his neck!?
[-] Recolour skin, cape, and tabard.
[-] Ugly colour scheme.
[-] Team colour is essential. Glow wont do it.
[-] It looks as if you have used Burn and Dodge a lot.

Positive Comments

[+] There are a fair amount of shadows and highlights.

Comments: Honestly, what is this?

Overall Rating: 2.5/5

 

[Ahsimpaquoi]

look the name (Forgotten One Eredar (Light Armored) it's a good skin ... 3.5/5

 

[Chuchurute]

hunnnnnn i don't liked it the brown used is strange

 

[Hawkwing]

It really needs pants, I'm sorry.

Edit:

hunnnnnn i don't liked it the brown used is strange

Agreed. It looks like Peanut Butter.

look the name (Forgotten One Eredar (Light Armored) it's a good skin ... 3.5/5

The name isn't important. Nor does the fact that he is lightly armored mean he needs to be pantless. It's a good skin? Why? Give reasons for what you say.

 

[pyropk95]

hmmm idk what it is but i dont like this SKIN...anywho 3/5 I MEAN SKIN!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Hawkwing]

You mean skin?

 

[Rajin71506]

Meh..not the best out there but there's something about it that i like..not sure what but its ok. 3/5

 

[terradont]

I do not think that the brown looks like peanut butter, more like breadsticks. Me likey breadsticks, Me likey breadsticks!
But in this case, i do not like breadsticks. To much recolour and i fail to see a good theme that the skin follows. The upper part is a regular purple eredar dressing in breadsticks and subs, the lower part is a regular purple eredar trying to be an incubus

2/5

 

[Incredible FX]

the brown is peanut butter the purple is jelly uugghhhhh horrible negative-1/5

 

[Lord_Firage]

the brown is peanut butter the purple is jelly uugghhhhh horrible negative-1/5

Uhm ... Do it better ... You have not done any Skin ..so dont Critism my work

 

[terradont]

Since when do we need to have submitted a resource to critisise? Take it with some salt man, most of us is trying to point out what's wrong wit the skin so that you can fix it, not to harass you.

Still, that's not very good critisising from incredibeFX

 

[Lord_Firage]

Yeah Terradont I know .. and its good that you all critism my Work ... But i dont like it if People which did not do any Skin /Model etc. but critism the Work of other people ...
Thats like ... your Signature ... XD

 

[Incredible FX]

Lord Firage nice try

 

[Lord_Firage]

.....
Now I dont know what i shall reply to that ... XD

 

[Devine]

Incredible FX
that aint no f*cking critics
dont repeat bad stuff others did just to piss someone off (troll)
and wtf? "horrible negative 1/5" omg dude, tell whats wrong dont just piss on someones work.

now my comment

i like the helmet and shoulders but i think you should plate the whole guy. I mean armor. And the freehand is realy blurry.

 

[Lord_Firage]

Ok .. I try to Full Armor him .. ( I even dont like the Chest xD)
And which Freehand do you mean is too Blurry ? the Upper one ?

 

[knight26]

Yeah Terradont I know .. and its good that you all critism my Work ... But i dont like it if People which did not do any Skin /Model etc. but critism the Work of other people ...
Thats like ... your Signature ... XD

just becouse some people dont have any skins/models, etc. doesnt mean that they cant judge a good skind froma bad skin.. remmeber once upon a time u were too justa member.

topic: Skin is a bit blurry at the armors on his sholders maybe sharpen it a bit ? 3.8/5 :O

 

[crl]

Brown? WHERE?!?

 

[Incredible FX]

but telling other people what they did wrong is kind of like helping

But what if I know how to make Models/Skins? What if I dont feel like making one huh!?

Ok guys enough of critism Lord Firage I actually like all your skins

 

[Lord_Firage]

*Off-Topic ON*

remember once upon a time u were too just a member.

I didn't Critism other people work before i uploaded my first Skin ......
The reason of my Registration was that i wanted to know what experience ppl think about my Skin...

Btw.. Incredible FX ... Is ur Account used by more persons than you or you just got Mood swings?
*Off-Topic OFF*

 

[Devine]

Ok .. I try to Full Armor him .. ( I even dont like the Chest xD)
And which Freehand do you mean is too Blurry ? the Upper one ?

all freehand is blurry :/

 

[Avsky]

I think it's ok, just change his helmet, shoulder-pads, the shading of his skin, and that dark shadow on his arm, then It'll be better. Right now its a 2.5, if you change those it'll most likely be a 4/5 easily. Great effort!

 

[War3_Editor]

Peanut butter jelly time!...... needs more freehand..... 2.9375/5, to be precise..... lol