BTNGnollSoothsayer

[Moderator]

15:49, 9th Feb 2016
GhostThruster: interesting art style, but overall he looks a bit too flat for a wc3 icon. get him to look a bit less flatter, shade his eyeballs + teeth, and lessen the shadows.

10:38, 12th Feb 2016
GhostThruster: upon re-review, the icon is good enough for approval. it could still use some better shading though

 

[JollyD]

~Reserved

Icon for Direfury's model

http://www.hiveworkshop.com/forums/models-530/gnoll-soothsayer-275019/

 

[Arad MNK]

Thought so

Nice icon. +rep

 

[Rex.]

This icon has a big problem. It looks more like a bat face. Look carefully... that small eyes, small teeth and the ears.

Ovarall, 2/5.

 

[Apheraz Lucent]

I'm waiting for detailed explanations of downgrading this icon in particular to 2/5 rating, which is "Lacking".

You can not rate a resource without suggestive criticism with THAT low rate. If no justifications will be provided, I shall remove your ratings.

 

[Apheraz Lucent]

Lacking is for icons of unacceptable qualities to even be approved.

I'm sorry if I was strict, but I really don't like when people don't appreciate that someone spent time creating something that might be used somewhere. I do hope you'll see things this way in future. There are icons that deserve low ratings, oh there's a hell plenty of 'em, but this one does not

 

[JollyD]

Actually it take about 1.5 hour straight forward for this icon, i will remake it with better shading

 

[WhiteFang]

I'm sorry if I was strict, but I really don't like when people don't appreciate that someone spent time creating something that might be used somewhere. I do hope you'll see things this way in future. There are icons that deserve low ratings, oh there's a hell plenty of 'em, but this one does not

This.I dislike it when people give low ratings purely because it doesn't look they wanted/imagined it should look.and like you said,this icon does not deserve a low rating

Anyway,the icon itself looks good and fits the resource it was made for.4/5

 

[Warseeker]

You should fix his ear

 

[JollyD]

Updated

 

[Apheraz Lucent]

Wicked! Love the small touches.