Moderator
M
Moderator
20:12, 25th Mar 2014
Hell_Master: Map Awaiting Update with a rating of 2/5 (Lacking). See moderator's review regarding the map:
07:54, 27th Mar 2014:
Hell_Master: Ratings changed to 3/5 and approved.
Hell_Master: Map Awaiting Update with a rating of 2/5 (Lacking). See moderator's review regarding the map:
Hell_Master;2503853 said:Review emerges!
I have played your melee map, Blood Dunes and I must say it looks decent but could have some little balancing for approval.
The terrain firstly is fine. Terrains ha ground variation is not flat but could use some smooth tool in sharp raises areas and because of this, there are presence of floating rocks which can be fixed by using the smooth tool on the sharp raises. Terrain has some decent amount of tile variation also. Terrain has some fine details in it, not that empty and is acceptable.
Now, on to the melee content itself. I seriously do not like the idea of Goblin Shipyard at the sides simply because it serves no real and enough purpose but just to travel at the other side of the terrain which could also be just reached through walking as well but the good side of it is that it provides more ways on ambushing your enemy bases. The amount of gold mines lacks as well for only one player can attain an expansion which can be pretty challenging which is good for other players but imbalance though. It would be pretty much suggested just to remove those shipyards and expand the land areas there and make those into gold mines. The amount of creeps looks totally fine but could use some orange or red camps instead of all green camps. Item drops looks good and randomize which should be.
Overall, this is promising but needs some work and this'll be approved in no time. Rated 2/5 and Awaiting Update.
07:54, 27th Mar 2014:
Hell_Master: Ratings changed to 3/5 and approved.