One Of the best wc3 drawings ever

[Dr. House]

This drawing is made by my dad for me i asked hime and now i wana show it here after a long time below the drawing you can see he made it cause he wrote his initials under it. he made it frome a image of a wc3 paper anyway here it is hope you like it.

 

[Deleted member 157129]

Not to sound rude, but it's not particularly good. Every sense of proportion and anatomy is thrown to bits. I mean, he's got an eye for detail, but there's not much quality beyond that. I mean, just look at the eyes for one. :/

 

[Dr. House]

ok so what would you rating be?

 

[supertoinkz]

I really like the gun (as always -.-) and the sketch, but as shiik said, the anatomy and proportion was

"OH JULIET, WHY DID YOU LEFT ME ALONE!"

especially that right hand, the eyes

 

[Dr. House]

ok i see what you mean

 

[dead-man-walking]

The Hands says it all... Right hand has Five Fingers where Lefty has Four (Plus Thumb). The best thing I can see is the Gun.

 

[Dr. House]

the left has 5 also just look better and you shall see

 

[Deleted member 157129]

ok so what would you rating be?

2/10 .. I guess.

 

[Aeroblyctos]

I don't like the eyes and the face but everything is okay.

I would say 7/10.

 

[Dr. House]

thanks i dont really see anything else bad besides that also

 

[Newominus]

Everythings good sept for hands, eyes and right cheek? And his head looks a little... Triangular.

 

[Pharaoh_]

Yeah, I wouldn't point so much at the rest of the body. The most stand-out flaw is the eyes from my point of view. I love the shading actually, it makes it alive, as if it was painted. I won't rate it, because I wouldn't have the right to do it. Just because he sat and made a childish-themed drawing (I mean come on, he is your father after all).

 

[dead-man-walking]

Well, some more things that I'd like to point out:
-The eye REALLY doesn't fit with WC3 Style
-The Shoulders and Face Proportions looks weird
-The cloak's ripped parts looks unnatural because of the same shape of the rips
-Hairy Face
-Nose is not flat enough for a dwarf
-Once again, the eye really don't fit WC3 Style

EDIT: Meh. Rephrased before this turns into off-topic starter.

 

[kola]

there is only 2 bad points in what i see. face and arms. rest is rly good.

hmm also, dead-man-walking, the way u say what is bad is insulting (well, if i would have done this drawing and someone would say me this, i would be insulted)

cuz pretty much all the drawing is good, except face and arms and hands.

 

[Kimbo]

there is only 2 bad points in what i see. face and arms. rest is rly good.

hmm also, dead-man-walking, the way u say what is bad is insulting (well, if i would have done this drawing and someone would say me this, i would be insulted)

cuz pretty much all the drawing is good, except face and arms and hands.

Its called having an opinion and pointing out errors based on opinion. Its up to the artist to agree if they are plausible errors and IF they want to learn from it, or take it as an insult, because its "the best".

 

[Dr. House]

well i supose som mistakes are indeed his own fault but you cant blame my dad for not knowing wc3 anyway i agree with the most things so

 

[Deleted member 157129]

there is only 2 bad points in what i see. face and arms. rest is rly good.

hmm also, dead-man-walking, the way u say what is bad is insulting (well, if i would have done this drawing and someone would say me this, i would be insulted)

cuz pretty much all the drawing is good, except face and arms and hands.

If you take criticism offensive, then you'll never improve, because you live in a bubble where all your art is perfect and every time someone points out something they dislike about it, you go all out defensive and claim it to be a personal insult for the sake of hating. I became the artist I am today because I got some pretty harsh criticism on my art early on and followed the suggestions, or improved the part which wasn't appreciated. I still receive a lot of criticism, and I heed every bit of what they say, so that I can continue to improve. There really is nothing useful, from a skill developing point of view, in comments that point out how awesome the drawing is, if they don't point out what could have been better. It's of course joyful to listen to admirers as well, it keeps you going, it just doesn't make you a better artist.

 

[Dr. House]

thats nonsence criticsm is somthing you should learn from and afcourse you dont have to agree with evrything but atleast dont see it offensive.

 

[kola]

well. its rly not the best and im not defending this. im saying that when u say someone to improve something u dont say

-Pedoface Expression
-WTF with the Left Hand? It looks like Three instead of Five
-Have I said that the pupils suck?

yeah shiik i know. but there is a way to say things. this i think isnt a good way to. and BTW this isnt my drawing. just saying that the way he said what he wanted to say is offensive. and if u say dont take it offensive bla bla. sry but this IS offensive.

u dont need to say me that if i want to bla bla be an artist bla bla. cmon i know that.

 

[The Reborn Devil]

I think it looks good. The proportions are a bit of, but it got it's own distinct look to it.

 

[chilla_killa]

I love it, I wish I could draw as good as your father!
Respect!

 

[Devine]

@kimbo and shiik, It's not what he said that's insulting it's the way he said it.

-Pedoface Expression
-WTF with the Left Hand? It looks like Three instead of Five
-Have I said that the pupils suck?

That's pretty offensive to me and it has nothing to do with being helpful, he's just bringing him down and trying to look all bad-ass. Besides, how does openly ranting about the artwork help (even if it was constructive) when his dad made this?

The only things I think need improvement are the right hand which should be bigger, (the eyes which should be more realistic and less... animelike)* and the right cheekbone which should be placed a little bit higher. Other than that, I like the drawing. The shading is pretty good. Gratz to your dad.
Edit: the second curve in the cloak should be toned down, because it doesn't look very natural the way it is right now, it should be darker. Also, note that the weapon is pretty damn well made.

*The way it is right now, it could be Disney artwork which, lets face it, is more succesful than any of the artwork ever submitted here. But if your dad was aiming for a realistic drawing, he should have gone for curvy eyes.

 

[Dr. House]

Thanks for the comment. And i agree with what you say also this drawing is a bit old so i supose he could do better now anyway thanks for the last 3 comments thay are much better than som others if seen

 

[dead-man-walking]

Oh. Forgot some good things. The Rifle actually looks nice. The Hood and Shading were also proper. And the legs, despite being a little too long, is in nice position.

 

[Alfagar]

The face is not so good :/ I love the gun!!

 

[Showrstudios]

What everyone else said, but also, you really dont have a true light pint. There seems to be 2 suns.