BTNThunderstruck

[Moderator]

13:12, 2nd Oct 2009
Zombie.: The background and the effect are of decent quality, but seriously...

I'd advise complete reworking of the guy that was thunderstruck, preferably showing his face in perspective as the thunder hits him. Since I know reworking like that takes a lot of effort, at least try to zoom in on the guy, give it better impact effects on and around him, not just a blur and at least add him some highlights.

enjoy: No changes made. He needs highlights, and the figure is out of proportions. Rejected.

 

[stefanstan95]

 

[Panda]

Looks cool, like a zombie of some kind. Nice work.

 

[stefanstan95]

Thanks, no improvement tips?

 

[Panda]

Hmm. Maybe make less fog so you can see the lightning, or you could make more "Zombies" walking.

 

[stefanstan95]

got it.

 

[enjoy]

Maybe blend the edge of the man, so the edge won't look so rough?

 

[TheHunterKiller]

This looks epic, but the man looks like a stickman.

 

[Wraithling]

I like the picture as a picture. But when shrunk into an icon it is not very blizzard-ish. In fact I was comparing this icon with blizzard's "purge" icon (which i think is the only one similar in style) and then realized that "purge" achieved its blizzard-style because of a simpler background. The background of this icon can be said to be too.. artistic. Don't get me wrong though, I expect many to find this icon useful and will download it, but I'd just want to point out that one little thing.

 

[bigapple90]

youve been thunderstruck

 

[Dentothor]

way too plain. it needs a whole lot more to fill it in. try to zoom in on the person being hit by the lightning

 

[supertoinkz]

supertoinkz's system of rating icons

Shadows and Highlights:
The ground doesn't have lights, 2/5

Design and Effects
Nice thunderbolt and atmosphere you got there 5/5

Quality
even i smell smudge, it is great 5/5

Overall
12/15 vote for approval

 

[Zombie]

Legendary song, but another silhouette-based icon...