BTNSteelHelmet

[Scias]

The composition is a bit off since helmet with all it's heavy detailing is leaning too far to right, leaving the left side empty. There's a bit of a mess with light source like the chunk of light on the distant horn stands out specifically since I can't quite tell where the light on it would be coming from, and it's quite a sharp "cut" shape.
There's also a issue with this straight-cut square shape of the highlighted area, drawing a lot of the viewers attention away from the rest of the icon:

Impressive shading on the metal though, and a creative design as always! Keep up the good work.

 

[PrinceYaser]

The composition is a bit off since helmet with all it's heavy detailing is leaning too far to right, leaving the left side empty.

I don't know why, but when I move it to the left, it looks more off to me:

>>

Maybe it's just me, huh?

There's a bit of a mess with light effects like the chunk of light on the distant horn stands out specifically since I can't quite tell where the light on it would be coming from, and it's quite a sharp "cut" shape.

Blue rim lights? Well, they're coming from the left.. I'm not sure what issue you're pointing out, perhaps elaborating more? oO

Impressive shading on the metal though, and a creative design as always! Keep up the good work.

Thanks!

 

[Scias]

Ah sorry, I updated my post about same time you posted yours, I edit my posts after posting them too much haha, didn't expect such a quick reply.

I don't know why, but when I move it to the left, it looks more off to me:

I think you're overdoing it to the left now, need to find the right balance.

Blue rim lights? Well, they're coming from the left.. I'm not sure what issue you're pointing out, perhaps elaborating more? oO

Rim light is fine and looks good, the highlight I was referring to is this chunk here:

 

[Panda]

Quality is good, nice work. Approved.

 

[WhiteFang]

Very nice quality,also quite useful.The shading especially i really like