BTNRedSword

[Moderator]

13:46, 17th Oct 2009
enjoy: Add some more highlights to the handle, and then blend out the definition alittle, so it isn't so rough.

enjoy: The blade is blurry. define it more.

enjoy: I think you should start over :/ Get inspiration from other icons maybe, to how they make the shading and such, to give sharp edges ect. ect.

 

[X-OMG-X]

Looks quite good but isnt the shape of the gem a little wierd?
Anyways, good job on this icon. Keeo up the good work.

 

[Pyramidhe@d]

the handle is off centre. a stronger red glow will be advisable i think, in order to define the sword outline

 

[TheHunterKiller]

That looks...brilliant.
I think the handle should be smaller, i can't see much of the blade.

 

[Darkmoon Hero]

The handle's pretty good, but the blade is lopsided.

 

[kola]

i think its too straight... and the handle is a lil to big

 

[Revolve]

Thanks for comments. Will work on what you have said :3

Darkmoon Hero, what does lopsided mean? sorry :s

Edit: Updated!

 

[Darkmoon Hero]

the handle is off centre.

Sorry. This is what I meant.

 

[Revolve]

Updated!

 

[Revolve]

Updated again

 

[Pyramidhe@d]

the soft shadings on the blade makes it look like the sword is cylinderical

 

[NFWar]

the soft shadings on the blade makes it look like the sword is cylinderical

Agree ^^ handle is great. Make smudging line at center of blade or something

 

[Wraithling]

And the glow! Why are the glows always a dull red :/

 

[CloudWolf]

The sword is fantastic However, the background and glow need to be a little more defined

All in all though, great job!

 

[Revolve]

So fucking pissed right now. I've been working on a chestpiece for this Red Gem set, and it was really turning out awsome, and then Gimp decides to shut down. Could seriously kill someone >.<

I will update the glow, thanks all

Edit: Updated. Remade most of the glow.

 

[Palaslayer]

fine work. but outline it more. it also misses some shading...

 

[NFWar]

Now it is Jedai sword
Rly, defne blade by placing some line at center of it. also shade sides diferent.

 

[DJVingummi]

that looks quite nice 4/5

 

[Panda]

Everyone else has basically said the adjustments, But nice sword.