Btnrage

[Moderator]

5 May 2010
Pyramidhe@d: Too cartoony and doesnt suit the style.

 

[Pharaoh_]

It looks like a screenshot and it obviously doesn't comply with the Warcraft III lore/environment. Mind giving more details or WIPs?

 

[Etzer]

No.
Just no.

 

[Panda]

Not warcraft-like at all, even for a spell. Sorry :\

 

[BishopOfDoom]

Sure it doesn't fit Dota or anything serious like that, but it might work out for loap maps, or some minigame :S
And yeah here it is in 512²

Yeah I know it's kinda blurry

 

[War_Golum]

its too cartonish....

 

[BishopOfDoom]

Hm.. And what's wrong with cartoonish?

Reference picture

 

[War_Golum]

Cartoon does not fit the style of the icons of WC3

 

[War_Golum]

Cartoon does not fit the style of the icons of WC3

I hope it improves a lot or delete the icon

 

[Panda]

@War_Golum, No double-post..

Anyway, have you seen the icons in the icon section? they all match the warcraft theme, and yours completely makes the opposite, so i suggest fixing this, or deleting it.

 

[BishopOfDoom]

I won't delete it, it's either gonna stay pending or get rejected, i'm fine if you don't like it.

Besides not all maps are "WC3-ish."

 

[Panda]

That may be true? But, here at the hive i wouldn't count on this getting approved that's all im saying, end.