BTNMoonwellPotion

[Moderator]

14:33, 13th Oct 2009
Zombie.: Good work.

 

[TheHunterKiller]

Looks more like a sickle with blue glow, but it's pretty cool.

 

[Dentothor]

As good as this may look, it still has a lot of work to do.
The gem/orb in the middle is mostly a solid colour and looks kinda weird and not very round (you were trying to get a round look, correct?). ad some more shading to the edge of the orb to make it look more roundish. I can see some of it, but its not really strong enough to clearly see it.

For Example

as you can see, the orb has some shading along the edges to give it that more round effect. and the strongest highlighting is on the bottom-centerish of the orb (the top centerish could work too depending on your direction of light.

The metal parts also need a bit of work on the shading. The highlights are ok, but the shading along the left-hand edges of the metal look like they suddenly stop, making it look like a completly different thing (not part of the metal). The shape of the metal also looks a bit crooked and messy. try to round it out to look more elegant like elven artifacts are.

The glow is quite distracting to the icon as well. try to tone it down a bit.

3/5 Its good, but just a bit more work and it will be great.

~Dentothor

 

[Darkmoon Hero]

Looks more like an amulet with a big, blue gem in it to me. It looks sweet, I'm just not getting the "potion" feel from it.

 

[Panda]

Looks like a bow to me, But, you might want to make it more like a potion though.

 

[Greedforce]

Potion? No, no, no! It´s a ring...or?