BTNGlasswithfireFull

[Moderator]

00:51, 3rd Dec 2015
Sin'dorei300: If u really want to create proper icons urself, please read some 2D Art tutorials and practice.
These icons don't feature enough quality to be approved.

 

[Eldin HawkWing]

Looks Nice But Fix The Shape of the Glass. It's Unsymmetrical.
But Nice Shading You Have there.
Good Work 4/5

 

[WhiteFang]

As Eldin HawkWing said,the glass' shape has to be fixed.Other than that,not a bad icon.

 

[Warcraftplay]

Looks Nice But Fix The Shape of the Glass. It's Unsymmetrical.
But Nice Shading You Have there.
Good Work 4/5

Do you have a bad shading?

 

[Eldin HawkWing]

Do you have a bad shading?

NO
Its Good !

 

[Moy]

I'll quote myself

First of all, the shape of the glass could be more accurate. There are bumps or humps or whatever you call that on the tip of the glass. Also, that is obviously not a fire, imo that is lava. And I guess the icon makes sense since lava melts glass XD. The lava could be more 3D

 

[Sin'dorei300]

Like i said about the other icons of yours: in order to succeed, you have to learn certain things.
Here you can find sufficient material that might help you:
2D Art Tutorials, Art Tutorials/Books/etc.
You need to define your objects properly.
Improve the shapes, proportions,...
Choose a suitable color palette.
There must be a source of light, so, add shadows and highlights.
Please read some tutorials and practice(if you want to learn something).

If u really want to create proper icons urself, please read some 2D Art tutorials and practice.
These icons don't feature enough quality to be approved.