Btne

[Moderator]

08:31, 16th Sep 2009
zombie2279: Has potential, but it's really messy. The fleshy randomness should be toned down and the outlines of the eye should be given more contrast. You might also want to slap the cut effect with some outlines to distinguish it from the background, and try to use more even colors altogether.

19th Sep 2009
zombie2279: Changes not made, rejected until updated.

 

[Panda]

.:Ideas/Suggestions:.
1:The overall eye seems to be hard too see a bit, i suggest bringing it to life by sharpening and maybe adding more veins.
2:I would make the eye brow above the eye a little more see-able, at the moment its hard too see it.
3:Add some more shading towards the eye too make it seem 3-Dish.
4:All the colors you have are quite pale i suggest brightening them up a bit.
(All my recommendations to your icon, you can choose to use these or not, your choice.)

 

[AbstractCreativity]

I think it looks a bit... Messy. It's a tad hard to tell exactly what you're looking at by first glance. Try to make it a bit more... Warcraft3-ish ^^
A little more solid colours, perhaps. I dunno
Don't get me wrong. I think it's a great icon, it just doesn't fit the WC3 style.

 

[Dentothor]

WIPs or a full picture?

 

[Panda]

This looks much better, add ATC, and other Borders too.

 

[stefanstan95]

ok

That should cover it!

 

[Soul Theft]

awesome

 

[breebree123]

this is epic i may say, i like it, very creative
5/5

 

[MultiGod]

its a bit messy, there are some parts I dont like:
- the middle where theres 2 balls above and below the eye.
- the shading, its to shaded.
- Nad i say the eye is too redish.
4/5 for now.^^

 

[TheHunterKiller]

The eye is epic, but the stuff around the eye, looks strange.

 

[PsychoNerdial]

Wow, very nice^^

 

[AbstractCreativity]

A lot better now. You could still tidy up the eye's surroundings a bit more though
Keep up the good work