BTNCarrot

[Moderator]

16:00, 30th Dec 2010
Pyramidhe@d: The leaves look like green blotches. The carrot could use more highlights.

8th Jan 2011
Pyramidhe@d: No changes made

 

[darkdeathknight]

Full Pic please

 

[maxor_gan]

You mean this? It looks so different..=/

 

[Deolrin]

I suggest you remove the background and zoom in on the carrot a bit. Even if a part of the carrot wont be visible, some details can be saved and it might look much better and Blizzard-like that way.

I suggest you try to do something like this:

And I'm sorry for editing your icon without your permission, I hope that's fine by you.
Anyways, I also recommend you to make the green part a bit darker to fit better with the icons in WC3.

 

[maxor_gan]

Whoa...you made my eye open! Your suggestion really makes me see something new, simply inspiring! =)

Anyhow for the background perhaps I would decrease its intensity, because I need the coherency with other "vege" icons in my map.

Thanks dude for the tips! At least I had some of my problem solved. =D

 

[darkdeathknight]

The grassy bit could do a bit more work. But other than that is looks good, you recognise it instantly and it has good highlight and shadows.

 

[Deolrin]

You should also sharpen your work after you resize it. Usually a 65%-75% sharpen does the job.