Arthas vs. Illidan

[Moderator]

16:11, 31st Jul 2010
ap0calypse: Approved

 

[Blitzschnell]

ahh i will see

EDIT: hmm^^ a background sound is missing its good for the first cinematic
I liked the end as arthas attacked illidan the red screen, it was a good effect .
There is some negative things too like the camera but it doesn´t matters.
I dont want make you a bad feel )

 

[-Kobas-]

Well I didn't see any fog -.-
No music
Camera stop from time to time
Battle looks bad, units attack each other normally
Memory leaks + map has only 2 triggers

I will check it once again and leave full comment...

 

[HardOn]

Well I didn't see any fog -.-
No music
Camera stop from time to time
Battle looks bad, units attack each other normally
Memory leaks + map has only 2 triggers

I will check it once again and leave full comment...

what I would have said. but there is still room for improvement.

 

[matej]

i dont like cinematics..

 

[ModelTester]

i dont like cinematics..

Why did you even bother to comment? Comments like yours are meaningless and aggravate me to the fullest extent. Regards to that, please do not comment on maps because it does not help the creator enhance their skills at map making. Deducing from your statement, "I don't like cinematics", I can tell that you are most likely narcissistic imbecile, who desperately is crying for attention. Well . . . Congratulations you finally did get some attention by a person like me who is a critique and enjoys watching cinematic. Please do not waste people's time by posting your idiotic opinion. Thanks!

-
I will review this cinematic later when I have spare time.

 

[Lungdrache]

A classic map but don`t my kind of map.

 

[Vengeancekael]

As a member of the Group Map Reviewers, I will be reviewing campaigns/cinematics :

Review - Arthas vs. Illidan A cinematic by Bladon001 Camera : The camera is fine, the user can see everything "he should" be seeing. Terrain : The environment is fabulous, you've recreated the area around the frozen throne very well. Story : There is no real story since you've just remade the fight scene between Illidan and Arthas, however you've changed the moves and to be honest, they're not so impressive, Illidan just blinks a few times etc. and in the end they just slash each other. Animations : There are different moves and the animations fit. You have also used slow motion. Other : There are some grammar mistakes. Hiveworkshop : The description is acceptable. Overall : I guess this is a bit short and doesn't really have a story, but the environment is just fantastic and some moves are ok. Final Rating : 2/5

 

[light bolt30]

Great terraining for a cinematic like this. Hope to see more fight cinematics from you.

 

[Vengeancekael]

As a member of the group Map Reviewers, I will be checking approved cinematics again:

Compatible - X

Permission - X

Map already uploaded - X

Rules - X

Bugs - X

Genre - X

Section - X

Category - X [Contacting a moderator]

[X = Passed]
[X = Failed]

 

[ronix101]

EpicWar has better..............

 

[leonguzman]

amigo ta muy bueno siempre me gustan este tipo de mapas para mi esta bien pero no soy un experto en mapas ademas soy un amateur
aunque siempre tube una pregunta no tiene nada que ver con este mapa pero aprobechare a hacerla emmm saves como crear un portal que transporte a una unidad a otro mapa?

 

[Shadow Fury]

Cheap cinematic!

Where is the sky? Where is the fog? I asked myself at the beginning of the film.
The fight wasn't really good because they attacked normally each other. The spells weren't that impressive.
However, cameras and terrain were good.

I think this deserves 2.5/5 and I've been generous just to let u know.

Some suggestions
- Apply a sky and fog because without them, even the most beautiful terrains look bad.
- Improve the usage of cameras, even though they were decent in ur film.
- Do never let Heroes just attack each other normally as they would do when u play
- The spells were poor, add more effects to catch the eyes of the watcher. Some frost novas here and there will never let u obtain a nice effect.
- Import some effects and models, people r tired to see the old Warcraft units and effects

 

[deepstrasz]

Nice although not original.
Text does not match the words/voice.
Camera shaking a lot.