Khaz'amul

[Moderator]

16:38, 24th Apr 2010
DonDustin: looks really awesome.

 

[Boneknight]

Subscribing and if you dont like the pollycount i dont give a heck i wont ruin it any further so you can just reject it then

 

[NFWar]

Whaw ^^
Looks rly mightfull. Blood Elf style I gues.
584 polys are too much, dont you think?
Size is good.

 

[Alfagar]

WOAH! This is very AWESOME!

 

[Boneknight]

NF check orginal 1 and then post again and you will know why I say I wont ruin it further anymore

 

[Jacky The turtle]

its looks good
i see noting else to improve :/

 

[NFWar]

Ow yes... I see now. The original is biger and seems like have much more polys. Duh, I gues polys are not sucha problem since people don have old Graphic cards now.

 

[reason 3]

Damn..that's a nice one..

I love it, and gonna use it for sure.

5/5 from me!! - vote for approval!!

 

[Sunchips]

Poly Count
628

Recommended?

I think it's very unprofessional how most moderators judge..
In my opinion the judgement should be based on certain things assembled as: low file size? Good wrap? Useful? Unique idea?

It's like if you would do a model with 1k polies then it would probably look really damned awesome and you would get recommended?
Just saying I think it's wrong.

Nice sword though.

 

[Misha]

...... are you sure this is yours? Looks a lill like WoW-weapon..
and the polycount is unusual for an attachment.. Oo

 

[Boneknight]

it was made for a high polly challange with mulgrim some wips there and it was inspired by one wow weapon, it was much more huger it was over 1 k pollys

 

[D a w n]

Poly Count
628

Recommended?

I think it's very unprofessional how most moderators judge..
In my opinion the judgement should be based on certain things assembled as: low file size? Good wrap? Useful? Unique idea?

It's like if you would do a model with 1k polies then it would probably look really damned awesome and you would get recommended?
Just saying I think it's wrong.

Nice sword though.

well...it is a nice sword, with a better design compared to most others submitted here. But it just has a nice design, it misses some effects like particles, ribbons or texture animations to make it rewally awesome.
Oh and about your judgement criterias: for this model it would be: low file size: yes, good wrap: yes, useful: yes, unique idea: yes. But just because it meets these criterias, it still does not deserve a dircetors cut, because most of the submitted models meet those standards.

 

[Boneknight]

well it has animated texture on blade i updated it also i will probably add some particles

 

[D a w n]

ok will do another review after you've added the particles

 

[Misha]

I wonder is the problem maybe in the model itself? Maybe it has a doublemesh :3 like some of my models.

I'm gonna run a test on how much polys i can shave off this without compromising a single detail :3

EDIT: *sigh* No doublemesh..

 

[War_Golum]

awesomezorkens

 

[paladinjst]

u added texture animations with war3 model editor , right? and the texture animations can not be saved by it . so the animation doesn't work ... but it's still a nice sword ... i give u 5/5

 

[chilla_killa]

I would make the Material of the CrystalOpaque texture to Filter Mode Add Alpha.
Then it looks more like a crystal.
Nice sword anyway. I love the BronzeDragon part.

What a pitty that the poly count is so high.
On the BronzeDragon part you could have made less polies with the same result, but it would be dumb to remake it.
Will you fix the texture animation?

 

[13L4M3]

God... i can't get my finger on what WoW weapon it is...
Nvm, great detailed sword here. nice.

 

[Sunchips]

well...it is a nice sword, with a better design compared to most others submitted here. But it just has a nice design, it misses some effects like particles, ribbons or texture animations to make it rewally awesome.
Oh and about your judgement criterias: for this model it would be: low file size: yes, good wrap: yes, useful: yes, unique idea: yes. But just because it meets these criterias, it still does not deserve a dircetors cut, because most of the submitted models meet those standards.

no its not on the low scale, its on the mid scale actually

 

[choji]

in my opinion its perfect

 

[RevansPhone]

@ 13L4M3,

'Twould be Ashkandi.

 

[Boneknight]

updated it

 

[KayS]

Mmm... Delicious 5/5!