I'm definitely down for the classic 'hooded executioner' thing, but I'm not quite feeling this one, and I'm not entirely sure why... Maybe in part the textures used on the metal spiky armor (seems kinda dull in comparison to the skin)? A lot of detail on the armor as well.
Tillinghast's Executioner is sort of the other end of the spectrum; much less detailed but kinda in that Warcraft-y way, which I think is more preferable for Classic. His could use a more interesting weapon (something yours excels at), and while the guy is masked it's not the classic spoopy pointy hood like yours. Hm.