Moderator
M
Moderator
20:54, 13th Aug 2010
ap0calypse: Rejected
ap0calypse: Rejected
(2 ratings)
sounds boring and just like another madball arena, what kind of mode and other feature apart from what you mention above?
Why don't you play the game first and then comment?
nothing personal, it's just that boring description that sounds a lot just like another map doesn't make anybody appealling enough to download it.
Why not add some screenshot or video to your description along with detail of what makes this map different than other map of the same genre out there? It doesn't hurt you to do it.
Yeah well even if a map has a good description with enought eye-candy that doesn't meen that it's gonna be good content. Like some of your maps I could mention nothing personal
P.S. Don't judge a book by it' cover
Yeah well even if a map has a good description with enought eye-candy that doesn't meen that it's gonna be good content. Like some of your maps I could mention nothing personal
P.S. Don't judge a book by it' cover
Ok I don't know how to say this but I will tell you few things you can like them or not, but thrust me nothing personal about it, just professional!
Ok I saw your map and first thing that I can see is map review, then I think 2 ogres strange name wtf is this! I open map! then I see playable size 32x32 see map category and type, and I think how can this one be good map with only 32x32 but I want to check more, I check map description, damn no colors, tables, video, poor screenshots without description about them, I read few thing about description, then I move mouse pointer to map preview to see terrain, looks ok for this kind of map so I still don't know everything about it, and at the end see this 351.15 KB! Now I know 50% about your map you can thrust me or not!
ok let see.... 351.15 KB means:
you have map preview that means in best way 200 KB
so map has 151.15 KB left
now come imported stuff like Loading Screen dude no room for that, no models no skins no nothing just base blizzard models!
Terrain alone takes 25 KB maybe more
So you use 100 KB for triggers and all else stuff
Dude I don't need to try map, I know that it is bad!
Ahahhaha we are not we just increased, call it, map control qualityOh god. Where did this section degrade? You people are fucking judging a map by the amount of custom models? By the description?
Wow. That's it... I officially declare it, we are EpicWar 2.0.
Maybe you are right but I see that you didn't checked my work so farBEFORE you judge\review\moderate a map, you MUST download it, play it THOROUGHLY(which means NOT for 1 minute or so), and with the recommended amount of players. Otherwise your review is worth NOTHING(except for ap0calypse who apparently rejected the map because the description looked like the map is bad).
Linaze was the last good map moderator... And look what happened; PurplePoot quit because that's how hopeless the Hive has became, then of course he quit. Great...
Oh god. Where did this section degrade? You people are fucking judging a map by the amount of custom models? By the description?
Wow. That's it... I officially declare it, we are EpicWar 2.0...
BEFORE you judge\review\moderate a map, you MUST download it, play it THOROUGHLY(which means NOT for 1 minute or so), and with the recommended amount of players. Otherwise your review is worth NOTHING(except for ap0calypse who apparently rejected the map because the description looked like the map is bad).
ap0calypse said:meatfactory said:Ahm... http://www.hiveworkshop.com/forums/maps-564/tumbler-169175/#post1675196 Rejected? Care to comment on this? Have you even tried it or is it the 2nd time you look at the comment of -kobas- without even taking your time to test it? The map really needs an update but rejecting it is a bit... extreme. And since it's in the "needs fix" section what do you think needs fixing?
My complaint: look at the status before complaining.
This color: temp. rejected (aka "Needs fix").
This color: perm. rejected (aka "Rejected").
Instead of ranting on about your map being permanently rejected, look at the actual status.
It will reset to pending once the map's been updated.
ap0calypse said:meatfactory said:My complaint: look at the status before complaining.
This color: temp. rejected (aka "Needs fix").
This color: perm. rejected (aka "Rejected").
Instead of ranting on about your map being permanently rejected, look at the actual status.
It will reset to pending once the map's been updated.
I DID noticed that and didn't "rant" about it being permanently rejected ->And you did not answer my questions.And since it's in the "needs fix" section ...
"rejecting it is a bit... extreme."
Look, it is NOT extreme: it is one of the most commong things on the hive, far more common than approving maps.
And if you look at the pending stats, you can see a "0 pending maps" somewhere, so we basically HAD to moderate your map.
If a map doesn't qualify the current standards, I reject it - leaving it pending wouldn't be productive at all.
Just fix what you think needs fixing, I didn't download your map.
ap0calypse said:*sigh*, whatever.meatfactory said:The point is there is nothing to fix and if you have bothered to test it you would know that (everything is working fine and map is fully playable in multiplayer) the only thing that I have in mind by updating it is just adding some skills and items and improving AI [optional].
There are no errors in the game.
So if I understand correct by saying:
you just put it under "needs fix" without any kind of testing... very unprofessional. That is kind of insulting after the work I put in this!Just fix what you think needs fixing, I didn't download your map.
I won't reply anymore.
Not in the mood, go whine at someone else, I'm tired of being whined at.
Unprofessional? Sure, whatever you say! If you knew how it actually worked, then maybe I would've cared.
The reason why a good description is necessary is to encourage players to play your game.
It will grip the attention of people who (accidentally) pass by, attention is one of the basic things a map must have, otherwise it will be forgotten in the thousands and thousands of maps on battle.net.
Every time someone passes by your map and pays attention to the description, is a step closer for your map to get famous soon.
Not only will it get famous: more people will respond, more people will find bugs, more people will try to help you and not only the map will get better, but it might be possible that you improve your own mapping skills.
Off Topic :D said:I want to say that I posted only GUI tutorials that can be found on THW you can also visit many other sites like wc3c or the helper net etc etc...
Why GUI, well I know Jass a little, I can understand but I can't explain it, so I posted only stuff that I can help you with!
Also if someone see that some new tutorials are uploaded or maybe deleted tell me so I can fix list, thanks!