Moderator
M
Moderator
Re-moderation:
ap0: Rejected
18:01, 16th Jul 2009
PurplePoot: I'm "rejecting" this not as an actual rejection but just as a tag to let you know that I've looked at it--it will automatically be reset to pending status when you modify it. I don't doubt that you have permission for this map and know it's been around for a while. It's a fairly fun map, and I'll have to make sure it credits imported material and all but is for the most part likely to be approved.
However, could you please update the description to include some description of the gameplay? A screenshot or two would be great as well, but by no means necessary.
Reasons: Other: If you have any complaints or questions directed towards a moderator, make a thread here: Map Resource Moderation If you think the moderator's judging is unfair or you have overall complaints, make a thread here: Admin Contact Please read the rules thoroughly: Rules Comment: Review: Gameplay: The map features a wide variety of ships, early on you only have a really useless and not so cool looking ship, however you can quickly get a better ship and you have a lot of choices, maybe more than 50 ships. The weapons are also really flashy looking, although some of them aren't really medieval like weapons, but hey it's just a game. The weapon doubling feature is also really cool, allowing you to upgrade a weapon and keep improving your ship even though you have 6 weapons equipped. There are also a lot of weapons to choose from and every ship has its own special ability(ies). Every ship does have the 3 basic passive abilities, although please do give them passive icons. There are also different roles in the map, you can either attack the enemy by following the basic 'AoS' type lanes with AI support or be a trader and get wares and items. Terrain: The bases look really cool, you've used matching custom building models and tower models, everything looks very polished, however it still feels a bit empty, there are no rocks, plants or anything around towers that are in the middle of the ocean on a very tiny island. And the areas to the right are really shallow and empty, just some blizzard cliffs with no plants or anything, maybe make some huge archs or something, or a gigantic waterfall area. Other: A neat looking loading screen+preview image, the in-game text is short, well written, informative and colorized. There's also a quest log with tips, the objectives, ... You've also used neat custom icons for the UI as well and also a custom UI texture, making it look fresh. Suggestions: *Bind the skill hotkeys to QWER *Add text to the exit button like 'Menu' or 'Exit' Overall: A neat mod to a great map, although not a lot of huge features and not that many new features and the terrain could have been better. |
18:01, 16th Jul 2009
PurplePoot: I'm "rejecting" this not as an actual rejection but just as a tag to let you know that I've looked at it--it will automatically be reset to pending status when you modify it. I don't doubt that you have permission for this map and know it's been around for a while. It's a fairly fun map, and I'll have to make sure it credits imported material and all but is for the most part likely to be approved.
However, could you please update the description to include some description of the gameplay? A screenshot or two would be great as well, but by no means necessary.