UndeadWarden

[Moderator]

THE_END: Basic recolor and not that good freehand either

 

[PsychoMagnataur]

first time? looks good to me

 

[THE_END]

First time is very good to start! Hope you like skinning you skilled at this !

 

[Lord Finarfin]

Excellent skin. 5/5

 

[Konblade]

Not sure how it was made, but it does look very cool.

 

[Wormskull]

crap skin, too much recolor, not enough freehand. the amounts of change are minor and it doesnt really change the overall concept of the unit. first skin might be low quality, but the efforts gotta be massive, but i dont see efforts nor determination in this skin.

 

[PsychoMagnataur]

"...does't change the overall concept of the unit."

It was changed from total green foresty to red evilish. Also, i'd rather see good recolor/cnp/filter than crap freehand, expecially from a newb.

 

[Eusira]

Ok for a first time, possibly excluding the fact it's kind of huge for a skin, probably because of resolution. 4.5/5 for first

 

[Ezekiel]

Why doesnt wormskull get it that not everything needs to be completely different. If it looks good ingame who the hell cares if its not a total make over. Yes i came out of no where.

About skin. For first skin thats really good. Hope you keep trying cause it seems like you could get pretty good with some experience. Only thing i find outa place is the wings on the back. In game they seem to not contrast very well with the rest of the skin.

 

[Mr. Clean]

-I agree. This skin embodies why I believe that my arguement that people shouldn't flame the work of others solely on the basis of how the skin was made, but should rate a skin based on how good it looks when attached to the model (unless it was a stolen work) is a valid arguement. I say this from the perspective of map makers, the people most likely to believe that the primary purpose of skins are to be made for use in maps and therefore should focus on looking great when wraped around the model.
-For a first skin, this is very well done. Keep skinning.

 

[Metabee]

WARNING, GOOD SKIN

 

[Elunes Guardian]

looks very good. Good Job I say

 

[Hemlock]

Promising skin!

 

[l)eMoN-)(uNtEr]

........... ill tell you what this skin sucks i mean come on whats wrong with it its stupid........... oh i mean JK :lol: its really good skin 5/5

 

[conqueror18]

I have a problem. The editor doesn't identify the skin. I put the path in the importrator and doesn't go. Please, tell me what to do. Thank you.