• Read Evilhog's interview with Gregory Alper, the original composer of the music for WarCraft: Orcs & Humans 🔗Click here to read the full interview.
  • Listen to a special audio message from Bill Roper to the Hive Workshop community (Bill is a former Vice President of Blizzard Entertainment, Producer, Designer, Musician, Voice Actor) 🔗Click here to hear his message!
  • Read Evilhog's interview with Gregory Alper, the original composer of the music for WarCraft: Orcs & Humans 🔗Click here to read the full interview.
  • Listen to a special audio message from Bill Roper to the Hive Workshop community (Bill is a former Vice President of Blizzard Entertainment, Producer, Designer, Musician, Voice Actor) 🔗Click here to hear his message!

Rating Meter

Status
Not open for further replies.
Level 16
Joined
Sep 3, 2004
Messages
2,086
Kind of reeling from that essay, we can all share how we "rate" people's things

Maps
-Stolen/copied-Do you suck eggs?
-Altered Melee using possibly stolen concepts-Is your brain working?
-Sloppy Map-Can I torch you?
-Somewhat good; A lil cheesy-Nice Job--Can I shake your hand after I cough into mine?
-Nice map-Can I give you a prize of -$.20?

Skins
-Paint- Fry in hell
-Filters- Do you like arsenic? You'll be loving it soon
-Recolor- Can I torch you?
-CnP- Can I fly a shrapnel kite 3 feet away from you?
-CnP+Redraw- I like your skill; can I pick your brain?
-Freehand- I'll play you roulette. If you land on a red notch, this bomb will blow your teeth into your skull

Models
-Anim Transfer- Can I rip out your spine and beat you with it?
-Stupid Merges- Can I stick a dagger into your chest and kick your dying body?
-Merges- Nice Job. I give you a C+
-Reskins. Look up freehand skins
-Skinned models with too much res for textures-Can I recommend you beat yourself?
-Nice models like Cookie's- Your a god. That's $2.50 for the appraisal

Icons
I don't give a **** about icons as long as they aren't
-Paint
-Weird ones with little object and lots of background
-Really stupid recolors

Can anyone show me their rating curve?
 
Level 13
Joined
Jul 28, 2004
Messages
1,340
(something i saw yersterday) = you dont deserve to have a computer
excessive rcf (recolor cnp filters) = not worth looking at
half rcf = very bad, its making me depressed
pins equivalant = ugh thats bad, why dont you try some freehand?
freehand, but only changed 50% of the skin = it doesnt look very different... please dont skin ever again
100% freehanded skin = great, but the changes are excrement
me = woah, you're such a god!

icons ( no one have them right )
recolors= die
icons that doesnt make sense/doesnt have a point/obvious/self-explainable = i dont think you get the point of iconning...
a resized screenshot from wc3viewer = goddamn lamer
a poorly edited icon = please, delete your painting program or something
a cnp from god knows where = all the things above
a totally new icon, something clear and suggestive and well-made ( think day of the fish ) = oooh, now it starts getting useful

it was hard to put it into words
 
Level 11
Joined
Aug 4, 2004
Messages
978
About maps:

If they suck, I pull out the gasoline and matches, with no questions asked.
If it's an okay map, I try to point out what could be done better.
If it's a good map. I vote either 4 or 5.


About skins and models:

I don't care about what methods are used, as long as it looks good. But if it sucks I go straight for the delete button, but if it's good I might vote, if it really kicks @$$, then 4 or 5.


About icons:

I don't really care, but if it's some crappy thing done in paint, I call in the torch wielding angry mob.
 
maps: ill agree with the public since i lost my cd.

Skins:
stolen- why hasnt this been deleted yet!
relcolor-why hasnt this been deleted yet!
crappy cnp-why hasnt this been deleted yet!
good cnp-the skin is good, but you show no skills
crappy freehand- wow this sure does suck, dont submit anything that you know people wont like
ok freehand- its pretty good but..(insert complaint here)
good freehand- wow this is pretty good but (insert smaller complaint here)
godly freehand- you stole this didnt you?


icons: nothing here, becuse icons are the least popular resource.

models:
crappy animation tranfer- so what? anyone can do this.
stupid models(like a cube or sphere)- odnt submit this, you didnt even make it.
crappy geomerges- stupid, why would someone use this
good geomerges- good, but you should try making custom models
good custom model- great! i only wish i could use this if i had my cd!

art:
recolor of already existing pics- stupid, you didnt draw this, your art skills are equal to of that who can color within the lines...wait you didnt!
bad sloppy pic- dont submit that drawing you did in math class the other day, it wasnt a blocked schedule so you didnt have much time to work on it.
decent pic- good but(insert complaint here)
awsome pic- great, youre one of the few who can submit decent art submissions here

tools:
all- how do you work this freaking thing!!!??
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top