Discussion in 'Poll Depository' started by Pyramidhe@d, Aug 21, 2010.
Aha, thanks for the info
LOL i'm not in the poll and i signed up and i uploaded my icons!!!!!
actually, you just posted Png version.
For this contest, I've decided to go for the icon set that fits best as attributes icons, disregarding how good they look as command buttons. So my vote goes to kola as I think they still look good when shrink-ed, and the colours are pleasing to the eye. An added bonus is that they can be used as the strength, agility and intelligence attributes too, even if kola did not intended that in the first place.
(side note: oops, I couldn't finish my icons in time, sorry debode ~.~)
if you dont remember
bananaHUNT won this shit, bai
Obviously. His were original and looked shit hot.
UnholyDobry deserves some credit. They would look awesome in some sort of Sparta/Greek/Roman RPG.
Not sure this is an improvement:
You lost all the detail of the guys face for Defence. And all the muscle-definition on Attack was mushed out.
An icon should be detailed, but clean-cut. You [kola] sort of lose the clean-cut appearance and all of the detail goes out the window (along with my vote!)
As I mentioned - I just like the clean-cut simplicity of BH's entry. Not to mention the fact that it is so unique and it just stands out.
yeah, its because, this way the old one looks good, but when converted to blp it looks like shit. my new ones are much better in-game than the old ones.
I still don't know who should I vote, I would sincerely vote for bananaHUNT, since I really like the wcish' style it has, but, I CAN'T find in any way, how can they fit as ATT icons, and considering the contests is about the ATT and not the BTN, well, I have a lot reduced options to vote for.
Uhh, what's the problem with seeing how they would be attributes? Leadership, Manipulation and Charm. Everything that a good king needs!
No, no, I speak up for the style, I loved the idea and the execution, but in my opinion I unlike how the style looks into a ATT icon, they fit more for a BTN. By the way; it's just a self opinion.
Don't get me wrong, but I didn't like that much banana's icons, not so Wc3 style for my eyes. Maybe it's just me. Though they are very well detailed and they look really good.
On the other hand, my vote goes for LightSkin, I really like the simplicity on icons. Best to make them not too loaded because sometimes they suck because of overdetailing as icons size is extremely limited. Just my opinion.
About all icons here, nice work ppl. I really liked the overall.
i really like banana's icons. Escpacially the manipulation icon. You could use thoose icons to so many things! therefore my vote goes to him. But the others are well too. Keep it up!
I love contests!
I voted for Kola because it represented something like it would look in game
My vote goes to bananaHUNT.His idea i very original.
How could someone actually vote not banana?
Devine and SuPa-: how's the judging going?
supa- is done. i am waiting for devine
The poll will be closed on the fourth.
That still gives me time, RIGHT?
Don't push me >:/
How many times has judging finished before the poll closes? Very few
Separate names with a comma.