Need help deciding

[Da)sniper]

I need help deciding what I should do for my map. I have 2 ideas and I think both could be a really good game if they where done correctly but I only have time for 1.

To do for new idea

Make it so ladders would work
Make all new terian
Find or make a sniper system that doesn't make you're unit move.
Make a "drop shot (when you shoot from far, far away your bullet tends to drop before going to target) system
Make a throwing system with height and timing
Some skills
A customization section
The animations
Some models
+ more (I forgot the rest)

To do for old idea

All the skills
The cloning
The cut scenes
The models
The animations

My old story idea

 

[Discipline]

Well... this is kind of an idea forum thread, but anyways.

It's hard to say which is a better idea because....

1. You don't actually show or say what your map is/is about on this thread
2. The ideas are kind of vague
3. The ideas are basically the same in a vague sort of way

Yeah... so idea 1 you do a bunch of skills, models and animation... oh and some systems, but with idea 2 you only do skills, models and animation. So normally I'd say, hell, idea 1 offers more so why don't you do that, but NO.... mainly because a bullet drop system is a crap idea. I don't really know even any first person shooters that boast about a bullet drop system, so it's probably not going to be too exciting in a strategy game.

Post some idea's that people can actually compare both to each other and your map and you might be able to get some real suggestions.

 

[Da)sniper]

Oh yeah I forgot to add. The old idea has some stuff done that the new idea does. And for the bullet drop system its added for realism.

 

[Zombie]

I don't really understand what map we're actually talking about either, but I like the new idea better. It sounds much more interesting and enjoyable.

 

[Da)sniper]

Oh yeah, forgot to add that huh? Heres the link. The game