BTNFieryBallThingy

[Moderator]

17:25, 4th Nov 2008
Hawkwing: It looks really cartoony.

 

[Paladon]

Overall a good concept. But the fireball doesnt really match with the background.
Its a 5/5 Upgrade icon. But not useful for a spell at the moment.
Either let the fire match more with the backround or make a water/ice, wind, earth one in this style too.
4/5

 

[Blaxor]

I could make it a attack icon etc. if you would want to ^^ it isn't that much work to fix

EDIT: I fixed the ATT and UPG icons enjoy

 

[Paladon]

Its a good attack icon.
Now make a frosty too^^

 

[FrIkY]

Sorry, but this icon does not appeal to me, but I didn't say it's bad, but you should consider about changing the background...

3/5

 

[Silent_One]

I'd tell you to change the background, it flows into the fire making it harder to see but still, awesome icon. Make it perhaps plain black or a faint glow. Awesome concept, make other elements too !

 

[Blaxor]

thx for the tips i might change the background AND make other elements ^^ i just need to figure out how it would look nice with something like ice or water

EDIT: i remade the background but i'm not sure if i'm going to use it
fieryball

 

[Silent_One]

EDIT: i remade the background but i'm not sure if i'm going to use it
fieryball

It's better but not quite there yet, I'm not sure what needs changing but it needs that special touch. Good 'thou.

 

[Blaxor]

kk i feel there is something missing but can't figure it out ^^ something special that is

 

[Paladon]

Its missing this funny whirl^^

 

[Blaxor]

i'll try to work something out ^^ something that blends in but doesn't ruin the flame

 

[Silent_One]

i'll try to work something out ^^ something that blends in but doesn't ruin the flame

Exactly my thought! Keep going at it my friend!

 

[HappyTauren]

Needs more contrast... all the red blurs together.

 

[Blaxor]

gah this is hard to figure out oh well i'll come up with something and fix it as soon as i get home tomorrow

EDIT: HappyTauren i know that the red blurs together, that's why i have been trying to come up with something other for the background..

EDIT 2: Still haven't figured out how i should make it look nice

 

[Paladon]

Do you allow me to make some graphical adjustments on your icon?
I wont post the results anywhere of course.
Then i may tell you what you can improve here.

EDIT: Damn >.<
This icon has a special touch. Every try to change it in any way destroys that effect. It does not really match to the most of the warcraft 3 icons.
As i said before, create a water/ice one, a rock/earth one and a storm/air one too.
If noone else figures out what to do with this one, leave it for now.
Great damage type icon.

 

[Blaxor]

i can send you the photoshop file if you have photoshop

EDIT: I have remade the background now if you liked the old ones better (with the twirly things) just pm me and i'll send them to you.

EDIT 2: Why hasn't the icon changed?

EDIT 3: Has a mod seen this icon yet?

 

[Paladon]

1)If you make an elemental set, the whirl looks better. If you dont, dont change it for now.
2)It takes some time but if you wait some minutes the icon changes after you updated it.
3)Dont know.

 

[Silent_One]

Omg! Awesome! I see you've changed it! Looks so much better now without the twirl. Great job. +rep.

 

[Panda]

5/5 ^^

 

[KelThuzad]

I didnt red previous comments, but Concepts are not good in wc3. It would've been nicer for like a wallpaper, but not in wc3. Still, 5/5 for the concept, 4/5 for the Icon.

 

[Jack_Sparrow93]

Great Icon, but it hasn't the "wc3 style"...