(10)Felwood Sea V1.6

[ZLY199377]

　　This map has some details that need to be improved.

　　Some players start from a small area, narrow road, resulting in units can not pass. In addition, the trees are scarce and the gold content in the gold mine is too much, so the Night Elves will be very popular in this map.

There are also neutral monsters whose camp is "neutral and invincible", not hostile. I don't know if it's the author's negligence or the author's intention to do so.

　　All in all, this map gives me the feeling of a battle map, not a confrontation map.

 

[Zucth]

　　This map has some details that need to be improved.

　　Some players start from a small area, narrow road, resulting in units can not pass. In addition, the trees are scarce and the gold content in the gold mine is too much, so the Night Elves will be very popular in this map.

There are also neutral monsters whose camp is "neutral and invincible", not hostile. I don't know if it's the author's negligence or the author's intention to do so.

　　All in all, this map gives me the feeling of a battle map, not a confrontation map.

Let's me answer this. some players like pink, yellow, and orange will spawn in a small area that's true so these will have the wall strategy base or two base with a connect in the mid... For me it's some kind of the challenge if it's not right with someone thought I will apologize.
Gold Mines are a bit too much, that's true I made it that much cause the map right now I was focus at the portals so protect your first base will be important but some how I will decrease it as you have said.
decrease trees? I didn't think of that or maybe I will think about that more next update.
invisible neutral monster? which one? Maybe I have forgot to change that, could you please mention the location and the unit name?
Thank your for the comment! and yep! this will be more strategy than just a normal confrontation.

 

[mafe]

Hello and welcome to the hiveworkshop.
I understand this is map is not meant to be a "normal" melee map. Most melee maps uploaded at the hiveworkshop are maps are intended to be "battle net ladder"-style maps. I tend to be quite critical with those.
So as this map has a different purpose, I'm not sure how to grade it.

However, several issues stood out to me, which in my opinion also limit the fun when playing with friends against the AI:
-Many starting positions do not have enough trees or enough building space.
-At the grey starting location (and maybe others too), creep will attack the main base if you build something.
-Many parts of the map are very narrow. It will be annoying to move armies past tiny choke points. Many ramps are bugged and have tiles where units cannot walk (check pathing by pressing the "P" button).
-It is impossible to build town halls (or other main buildings) near some expansions.
-I have no clue what the itemdrops mean for the gameplay.
-The map is using patch 1.07 game data instead of the current patch. Please use "melee (latest patch)" in the game data settings. Or make changes until it say "melee map: yes" in the bottom right of the editor.

Right now, the map seems very confusing to me. Please address some of the issues, then I will have another look. Until the, map set to Awaiting Update.

Also, please consider if you want the map to be classified as "melee" or "altered melee". You have used both tags, but they are meant to be mutually exclusive.

 

[Zucth]

Hello and welcome to the hiveworkshop.
I understand this is map is not meant to be a "normal" melee map. Most melee maps uploaded at the hiveworkshop are maps are intended to be "battle net ladder"-style maps. I tend to be quite critical with those.
So as this map has a different purpose, I'm not sure how to grade it.

However, several issues stood out to me, which in my opinion also limit the fun when playing with friends against the AI:
-Many starting positions do not have enough trees or enough building space.
-At the grey starting location (and maybe others too), creep will attack the main base if you build something.
-Many parts of the map are very narrow. It will be annoying to move armies past tiny choke points. Many ramps are bugged and have tiles where units cannot walk (check pathing by pressing the "P" button).
-It is impossible to build town halls (or other main buildings) near some expansions.
-I have no clue what the itemdrops mean for the gameplay.
-The map is using patch 1.07 game data instead of the current patch. Please use "melee (latest patch)" in the game data settings. Or make changes until it say "melee map: yes" in the bottom right of the editor.

Right now, the map seems very confusing to me. Please address some of the issues, then I will have another look. Until the, map set to Awaiting Update.

Also, please consider if you want the map to be classified as "melee" or "altered melee". You have used both tags, but they are meant to be mutually exclusive.

After look on what are you talking about I have change a lot of things, maybe will update soon. I will talked about the change later. Anyway thank for the tips of using 'P' it help me a lot. First I would say that English us not my first language so it has a possibility of miss understand or using I will change it. Second, this is a one big problem, I dunno how to make it change to "melee-map: yes" and for the game data setting I don't know where it is either(or maybe it because I have a custom unit?)... but I will make a update first.

 

[mafe]

After taking some time, I have come to the conclusion that this map even after the update is too far aways from anything that a melee player would expect.
Most of the issues which I mentioned in my previous post still exist.
Just for the sake of completion, here's the game data setting:

And the problems which you would have to solve to make your map "melee map: yes":


Map set to substandard.