Unknown shaddow

Moderator · Jan 21, 2011

12:23, 22nd Jan 2011
-Kobas-:
Map Status: Rejected
Broken Rules:
(Map) Credits, (Map) Presentation
Comment

shadire · Jan 21, 2011

shaddow = shadow
entre = enter
th = that
complet/compleet = complete
Just fixing some of the words in the sentence. Also remember caps at the beggining of sentences.
But anyways, the definition needs some screenshots, various subjects such as the story of the map and the different heroes. You have peeked my curiosity so I'll try the map.
Rating coming soon

shadire · Jan 21, 2011

I started playing and decided to try something: lets see if the villager can pass through the portal. So I start walking and *POW* it works. Shouldn't you make it so you have to choose a hero? Also some of the names are misspelled (letters and capitalization). This map does not seem to have any towns or shops of any kind, and those often help in RPGs. Along with quests asides than "Go through killing monsters and leveling up until you get to the final boss" There should be more complex things and maybe a few puzzles and a storyline would help with the RPG concept of the game.
I rate 1/5 and maybe you should try the section that's meant for test maps first.

sekte26 · Jan 21, 2011

If tested the map before uploading . I said the map is very simple and i dont like puzzles. so id would be very friendly when you dont rate 1/5

kidsoulex · Jan 21, 2011

"Nameles" - Nameless
"Threw" - Maybe through because of sentence
"on the map are different areas" - on the map, there are different areas
If this is so badly like the map some stuff may get confusing also use [url="http://www.hiveworkshop.com/forums/misc.php?do=bbcode]BB Codes[/url] to improve description further and also tell us more about the map like:
The ultimate objective of the map
The features(Like what makes this map unique)
The heroes(if not many describe each)
Credits(Also ingame)

Super-Sheep · Jan 21, 2011

sekte26 said:
If tested the map before uploading . I said the map is very simple and i dont like puzzles. so id would be very friendly when you dont rate 1/5

But in the Hiveworkshop uploading a low quality map is against the rules...

They also need to be in 100% english.
And have no grammar mistakes.
And have a clear map description.
And some other stuff that I can't remember.

sekte26 · Jan 21, 2011

on Epic war.com everyone likes the map!

DeadBoss · Jan 21, 2011

This is not EpicWar (Recycle Bin).

Aesthetics · Jan 21, 2011

You said:
Im from germany and my english is not very good

I was very understanding of this until..

You said:
If tested the map before uploading . I said the map is very simple and i dont like puzzles. so id would be very friendly when you dont rate 1/5

So if someone rated 1/5 for your map simply out of honesty, you'd be unfriendly against them? Really, I suggest that you go post this in map development and not upload it until you have received positive user feedback.

Super-Sheep said:
And have no grammar mistakes.

I'm pretty sure they don't have to be perfect, just decent.

sekte26 · Jan 22, 2011

You just dont understand maps like this. its german humor, like
the world war 2 or the DDR!

Aesthetics · Jan 22, 2011

sekte26 said:
You just dont understand maps like this. its german humor, like
the world war 2 or the DDR!

Let's assume just for a second that we don't live in a world where everyone agrees with your ideas and think about how basically everyone has a negative outlook upon this map except you; part of mapping is to please the players.

sekte26 · Jan 22, 2011

have you played the map and noticed the details? the skills are beautyfull and the map desighn detailed. you should deal with it for a longer time. i know that there are some fails but there are many positive points too. this map should be just entertaining and no nuclear physics!

light bolt30 · Jan 22, 2011

You need to have good grammar, get someone to translate or ask someone to check the spelling for you. Also improve the description, no one is bothered to read a wall of text; use colours, use tables, add screenshots, etc. Here's a list of BB Codes to help you. Also fix the author name and add suggested players. This map will not be approved anytime soon.

KingLich · Jan 22, 2011

Positive points...

sekte26 said:
have you played the map and noticed the details? the skills are beautyfull and the map desighn detailed. you should deal with it for a longer time. i know that there are some fails but there are many positive points too. this map should be just entertaining and no nuclear physics!

The only positive points I see in this RPG are the skills/spells models... gotta say I liked em. But the game is boring and easy... and lets not talk about the grammar issues

...

Aesthetics · Jan 22, 2011

sekte26 said:
have you played the map and noticed the details? the skills are beautyfull and the map desighn detailed. you should deal with it for a longer time. i know that there are some fails but there are many positive points too. this map should be just entertaining and no nuclear physics!

You really wanna list the positive points and fails? Here's my list:

Pros:
- Decent terrain

Fails:
- Melee init trigger with a few modifications
- 2 triggers of the utmost simplicity
- Spells are Blizzard spells that are modified to display horribly unprofessional descriptions and have their icons changed
- Extremely dull gameplay (kill kill kill)
- Lacks originality in the sense of abilities, heroes, and game concept

I see that it is 1 to 5, so basically it's not gonna get approved anytime soon.

-Kobas- · Jan 22, 2011

sekte26 said:
spam spam spam spam put your head between your legs and kiss your err... goodbye!
hahahaha
you realy need a hobby! go out, nobody likes know-it-all nerds like you!

I will come back tomorrow and moderate your map, I will be nice now but if I see any more comments like this one I will give you -1 rep for each bad word, hurry now and fix that.

Be nice to users ok, don't flame/troll/insult and so on, you already have some neg rep and I still go easy on you.
If you have problem in map section contact us map moderators.

Did I make myself clear. I warned you first and last time.
Take care.

kidsoulex · Jan 22, 2011

People here are trying to help improving the map by pointing the bad aspects so you can improve and you still insult everyone who talks bad about you, seriously...

Arcisal · Jan 22, 2011

Excuse me!
You're already violating the rules on Hive by uploading a map with a description a 7 year old can make. Just because the map might be good inside, it's still violating the rules. You need to have proper grammar too. Hive isn't "German" has you have said in your previous post. It doesn't need German humor.

Other than that, light bolt 30 was being nice to you. Don't swear or I'll report. If you don't think the Hive is good enough for your maps, then you can post on Epicwar if you'd like to.

-Kobas- · Jan 22, 2011

Moderation

Unknown shaddow
Created by Unbekannt ; Uploaded by: sekte26

Hmmm... Map presentation is really bad, you didn't described heroes, abilities, areas, monsters, quests and so on, there are no pictures or any other way to show your work. You didn't even listed witch systems you use and so on. You don't give credits for imported resources.

But then when I opened map I was able to see only 2 triggers.

RPG map can't be good with 2 triggers:

Nahkampf-Initialisierung
- Events
  - Map initialization
- Conditions
- Actions
  - Quest - Create a Required quest titled kill unknown! with the description (Name of Unknown (last boss) 0471 <gen>), using icon path ReplaceableTextures\CommandButtons\BTNAmbush.blp
  - Melee Game - Use melee time of day (for all players)
  - Melee Game - Remove creeps and critters from used start locations (for all players)
  - Melee Game - Run melee AI scripts (for computer players)
  - Quest - Display to (All players) the Quest Discovered message: Kill the last boss ...

and

Unbezeichneter Auslöser 001
- Events
  - Unit - Unknown (last boss) 0471 <gen> Dies
- Conditions
  - ((This trigger) is on) Equal to True
- Actions
  - Quest - Mark (Last created quest) as Completed
  - Quest - Display to (All players) the Quest Completed message: You haf killed him!...

Hero pick system is ok but you should add more things, like floating text above heroes and so on...

I picked hero and move on, grrr items on the ground, why?
You can create them and give to hero instead?

Way Gate to connect areas, ok...

Terrain isn't something special, average and sometimes poor...
I won't explain terrain because I can write 2 times more only about it than whole this review. Point is that you miss large number of special effect and lightning like effect doodads. Low number of environment doodads and so on...

Gameplay is well balanced but polishing is horrible, no any kind of score to display current status, no active quests no nothing... Active abilities use PAS icons and vice verse, English descriptions are very bad...

No modes, no difficulties, no special events and so on.

I will rate your map with 1/5 unacceptable mark and set map status to Rejected!

Broken Rules:
(Map) Credits, (Map) Presentation
Thread Cleaned:
6
Status: Rejected

Unknown shaddow

Unknown shaddow (Map)

Moderator

Moderator

Moderation

Similar threads