Agreed. but give the guy some pointers, dont just say rejection w/o any pointers to how to make it better. If it is going to be a story of Kael, a lore character, you should make the cinematic look epic. And that starts with several things you need to fix:
~Grammer: There are a lot of grammar errors that need to be ratified. There were run-on sentences and many words were just plain spelled wrong. Noobish writing.
~Positions: The worker ordered everyone to start moving, that bothered me....a worker should not command everyone to start working. Also, Kael should be more involved. All he said was...."Damn, whats wrong now?" and "Hurry up" (if I remember correctly) Involve the players more.
~Length: Make the cinematic longer....it was very short, very boring, not engaging at all.
Tips: Watch the frozen throne cinematics. They are very well done and are great models in creating a good cinematic.
Hope that helps
~Over and Out~