15:39, 27th Sep 2009
PurplePoot: Above all, the game desperately needs a spelling and grammar revamp--it was to the point where I was hard pressed to find out what many things were. The terrain did not particularly fit with the models, and above all imports were spammed left and right with no sense of coherency or relevance, just because they "looked cool".

The balance was alright, although with upgrades it became skewed and overall it was rather hard to evaluate. The gameplay did not deviate much from the Tech Wars standard, except was a little slower and more model spammy.

To be approved, it should really be more coherent and have proper English at the very least.

i will test later im guessing it does not have an AI but from what i can see
Credits 5/5
but as always there is an but. But description about the map itself is 2 lines if you count the line the sense of war
you should prolly make that better (to get approval

My rating

Positive:

+ Terrain Works
+ Big variety of units
+ Nice models
+ Balanced map

Neutral:

~ Nice map idea ( a bit like footy)
~ Bad mapprotection ( i easily deprotected the map with all functions and imports)
~ Too many credits in map discripiton

Negative:

- Too long start time ( Units to weak at the start no sence of attacking)
- No own loading screen; map preview
- Terrain could be a bit more creative

Solution to improve map:

To create a loading screen you need the warcraft 3 model editor here is a link where you can download it: http://home.magosx.com/index.php?topic=6.0.
Here is also a link for a youtube tutorial video about how to create a loading screen with the model editor:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vfz3RG0PLUA.
Also make some more money at the start.
I would make a sort of little platform at the middle of the map because it looks cool and it is always good to know when you are over the middle.
Worker could be a bit smaller too. Make credits as a quest in game because it looks confusing in your discription.

Fazit:

Nice game and makes fun with a bit too long start time. It could need some better map design as well. But without bugs and good gaming system.

MyRating: 3,84

Overflow said:

Positive:

+ Terrain Works
+ Big variety of units
+ Nice models
+ Balanced map

Neutral:

~ Nice map idea ( a bit like footy)
~ Bad mapprotection ( i easily deprotected the map with all functions and imports)
~ Too many credits in map discripiton

Negative:

- Too long start time ( Units to weak at the start no sence of attacking)
- No own loading screen; map preview
- Terrain could be a bit more creative

Solution to improve map:

To create a loading screen you need the warcraft 3 model editor here is a link where you can download it: http://home.magosx.com/index.php?topic=6.0.
Here is also a link for a youtube tutorial video about how to create a loading screen with the model editor:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vfz3RG0PLUA.
Also make some more money at the start.
I would make a sort of little platform at the middle of the map because it looks cool and it is always good to know when you are over the middle.
Worker could be a bit smaller too. Make credits as a quest in game because it looks confusing in your description.

Fazit:

Nice game and makes fun with a bit too long start time. It could need some better map design as well. But without bugs and good gaming system.

MyRating: 3,84

Click to expand...

Nice map, people on BNet seem to like it.

Well constructed and presented.

A very well made map. I like that one is forced to tech and that mass is almost impossible.
The models are awesome but credit here goes to the makers , but still a bit to you since you arranged them in the way they are here
Balance is a bit strong towards paper-stone-scissors and infantary seems a bit weak especially because infantary building gets 20 less income than the other ones. The hospital is an advantage but most units die with 1 hit so it doesnt get the chance to heal a lot.
But still this is already really hostable and so Im doing that.

Still, I prefer Castle Fight :-/

This map is good.
And its very well made.
Keep on the good work.