19:32, 12th Dec 2013
Kimbo: Hey there, can you please update this icon so the glow isn't so sharp and erratic? Just make it a soft smooth glow and smoothen out the shading on the ring and I will review it again, thanks. I will give you about a week to update this icon

Certainly the "warcraft-ish" style is achieved. However the glow around it is kinda weird, like it's cut off from a larger image. Anyways this is much better than the others in my opinion

Take some rep, Tuskar <3

Hm, this is good... But somewhat lacking (at least in terms of Wc3-style) in comparison to your previous icon (the Axe). Unfortunately, I'm not sure I can articulate exactly why. Wait for Ms. Lucent or someone else that knows what they're talking about.

//Brighter, more contrasted colors? Take a look at some of the in-game "Ring" items' icons, perhaps.

The ring it's nice, but what is that thing around ?
Is it an aura, a glow, or something else?
Whatever it is, spoils the look of the icon. Try to change it.