13:48, 14th Jul 2009
zombie2279: Rejected until evidence of genuine artwork is shown.

Looks pretty good! But I had a little problem telling what it really was for the first 5-6 seconds, so I recommend you enlarge the ranger, so you see MORE ranger and LESS black background

add a gray or green glow

Well you either need to make the ranger stand out more, or you need to make the bow stand out more because now it looks very undefined

just my opinion

Made in pencil? Err..


And can we see a bigger pic.

so i got 3 resize of ranger vote for your favorite and i will make an icon of it

what is this? too dark! err. .. .needs more highlights,detail,make it more bigger. .
epic fail. .1/5 unacceptable

-To breebree123: Unacceptable? Now that sure is going a bit too far. But that might be my opinion. (Anyways, no offense meant at all)
-To anrere: Of those three resizes, the 3rd one (furthest down in your post) is best.

... Well, all resources are a matter of taste, really...

breebree123 said:

what is this? too dark! err. .. .needs more highlights,detail,make it more bigger. .
epic fail. .1/5 unacceptable

Click to expand...

Epic fail? lol, come one this icon has a very great idea, lacking execution though...

Your comment demanded the icon-maker to become better, yet ironically ruined his..... enthusiasm... - very evil indeed.

I wonder why you people love to bully others' works through comment just to indulge yourselves.

Hmm, but yes, I'm agree with you the picture must be bigger (come on you don't need 'more' in front of 'bigger') so that the output becomes more detailed, and I think the dark ranger is too fat .

2/5 from me, but I won't rate it yet since I expect the creator to update his work .

put the ranger more into the center, add more definition, use less blur and this icon is epic.

Cannot see what it is. Sharpen the original image and resize it so that you can see everything, not in the bottom corner.

I think the archer needs to take up more place in the icon.

@ anere I really dont see a difference between pic 1 and 2, but I'd say you should make it one of them. Pic 3 is still too small :/

Good idea btw

To anyone having doubts, the three possible pics are of exactly the same drawing, but from different zoom angles/sizes. Anrere, I suggest you resize and post up all the pictures seen in that post here, in 64x64, preferably bordered, so users can actually see which one looks better.

Anyway, it appears to be quite good, but hardly anything is seen on the resized variation. By the way, can you please provide the .xcf file and/or work in progress screenshots?