21:09, 29th Dec 2015
Sin'dorei300: I strongly recommend you to add shading(highlights and shadows, using lighter or darker tones of your base colors), this will visibly improve your icon.
Awaiting update.

Is that really YourS? can you Show the Picture of your WIP.

-icon




-my draw





-reserved

Nice... But The Shading?
4/5 - Needs a Shading.

I recommend you to do more freehand shading.

Pretty nice. Was this icon inspired by this model? http://www.hiveworkshop.com/forums/...yes-199896/?prev=search=Champion&d=list&r=200

If you use compressed .jpg option with around 85% quality instead of palletted in button manager it could get possibly less grainy. Be sure it has saved the icon as 32 bit and not 24 bit.

Recommendations for this Icon to get approved
-Fix the symmetry for the hero
-Needs more freehand shading
-Remove the stray pixels between the lines of the icon
-Jesus Christ take out that god damn glow in that icon and make it freehand

Overall: It's decent, but still asymmetrical so I hope you can improve your icon and do your best.

The shading could be stronger, I disagree on the symmetrical thingy. It doesn't need to be symmetrically perfect imo.

As I said, the shading could be stronger. The icon itself is really great already and a small touch of shading could make this icon amazing and possibly approved. The gold part is the most obvious part to the naked eye that needs stronger shading. I recommend you to see Sin'dorei300's album to see what I mean, and learn from his artworks.

though the shading in the big image is kinda lacking, the result after it resized is beautiful for me.

reminds me alot of how sunchips do this icon : http://www.hiveworkshop.com/forums/...ggernaut4-260004/?prev=d=list&r=20&u=sunchips

Nice Update Warcraftplay..! 5/5
looks like LichKing's Helm .