BTNGomugomunomi

Moderator · Jun 10, 2014

20:40, 14th Jun 2014
Sin'dorei300: This looks the worst of ur fruit icons.
The details seem to be wrongly drawn.
Also it needs more shading coz of flatness.

16:29, 22nd Jun 2014
Sin'dorei300: The shading is lacking, it still doesn't looks spherical.

20:50, 22nd May 2015
Sin'dorei300: Commented.

Heinvers · Jun 10, 2014

I'd say that it needs stronger highlights and well defined shadows. Pretty so far.

The Panda · May 21, 2015

Its doesn't seem too round to me, but other than that it looks sweet.

Sin'dorei300 · May 22, 2015

If i understand, these are some cursed fruits and those who eat them get some magical powers.
However, they're like real fruits(texture-wise).
In ur icons they look rather like artificial fruits. Also, they look kinda flat.
I suggest u to improve their texture, shading/highlights, in order to get rid of that synthetic/artificial look.
Some of Hive's fruit & veggie icons:

The Panda · Mar 18, 2022

[~] New Icon Rules, this icon seems to be useful enough for approval considering old review.

BTNGomugomunomi

BTNGomugomunomi (Icon)

Moderator

Moderator

Heinvers

Heinvers

Resources

The Panda

The Panda

Resources

Sin'dorei300

Sin'dorei300

Resources

The Panda

The Panda

Resources

Similar threads