BTNDeathStrike

Moderator · Apr 10, 2009

07:36, 11th Apr 2009
Paladon:

Icon Review

Creativity: 2/5
Quality: 5-6/10
Status: Rejected until updated
Comment: You need much more definition. The sword sould appear stronger and more metallic. Right now, it looks like plaster.

Zombie · Apr 10, 2009

Better and might be more useful than your last one. You might try to add some shading and detail the effect a bit more, so it might get approved.

Dunno why, but it slightly reminds me of this icon..

og-loc · Apr 10, 2009

thank you all for your critic, iam a very noob icon-maker. Anyone knows a "gimp" tutorial for icons? i only found tutors for photoshop and other "money" progs.

lieutang · Apr 10, 2009

Not Bad. Can be useful.

X.e.r.e.X · Apr 10, 2009

That blade needs shading badly

og-loc · Apr 10, 2009

I add some shade now...

X.e.r.e.X · Apr 10, 2009

Much better, but the black line in the middle is bit too defined

og-loc · Apr 10, 2009

updatet again..

EDIT: updated*

BTNDeathStrike

BTNDeathStrike (Icon)

Moderator

Moderator

Zombie

Zombie

Resources

og-loc

og-loc

Resources

lieutang

lieutang

Resources

X.e.r.e.X

X.e.r.e.X

Resources

og-loc

og-loc

Resources

X.e.r.e.X

X.e.r.e.X

Resources

og-loc

og-loc

Resources

Similar threads