Thank you so much for summarizing everything into a single post. I will give you rep for that.
I don't think the winners should get +5 rep for a finished entry, that should only go to the participants who didn't get a spot in the top 3. I am sure that was the idea behind it.
Where does it say that judges get 10 rep? They deserve some credit, but the contest should specify things like that.
Both Wa666r and DED1 didn't upload anything and their posts mention WIPs. Does that count as a finished entry?
We can give Direfury an award none the less, but I have asked the judges if they perhaps have copies of Direfury's submission, also I have attached entries to posts where they are missing.